Group learning on social work placements

Authors

  • Trevor Lindsay

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.1921/gpwk.v15i1.573

Keywords:

<i>Group</i>, <i>practice</i>, <i>learning</i>, <i>social work</i>, <i>students</i>, <i>teachers</i>

Abstract

In the UK, as in most other countries, social work student learning is a combination of a college based education and placement practice (practicum). There is nothing unusual in practice teachers working with social work students in groups. What is rather surprising is that, in spite of the approach having been accepted for many years, it has attracted relatively little interest as a research topic. However, the benefits of groups for learning are well established and discussion on groupwork models of student learning in practice is to be found in the literature of other helping professions, notably counselling, psychotherapy, nursing and occupational therapy. It is also well established in the literature on staff supervision. This article reviews some of the literature on group learning and supervision and presents the findings of a research project which examined the experience of students and practice teachers engaged in group supervision on placement. While a small number of students had some reservations about their experience, feedback from students and practice teachers was very positive overall. The findings of the study are used to suggest guidance for good practice in this area.

References

Abercrombie, M.L.J. (1983) The application of some principles of group analytic psychotherapy to higher education. in M. Pines (Ed) <i>The Evolution of Group Analysis.</i> London: Routledge & Kegan Paul\nArkin, N., Freund, A., and Saltman, I. (1999) A group supervision model for broadening multiple-method skills of social work students. <i>Social Work Education</i>, 18, 1, 49-58\nArvidsson, B., Lofgren, H. and Fridund, B. (2001) Psychiatric Nurses’ conceptions of how a group supervision programme in nursing care influences their professional competence: A 4-year follow-up study. <i>Journal of Nursing Management,</i> 3, 161-171\nBamford, D. and McVicker, H. (1999) Group approaches within social work education and training. <i>Issues in Social Work Education,</i> 19, 1, 35-54\nBogo, M. (1993) The student/field instructor relationship: The critical factor in field instruction. <i>The Clinical Supervisor,</i> 11, 2, 23-36\nBogo, M., Globerman, J. and Sussman, T. (2004) The field instructor as group worker: Managing trust and competition in group supervision, <i>Journal of Social Work Education,</i> 40, 1, 13-26\nBorders, L.D. (1991) A systematic approach to peer group supervision <i>Journal of Counseling and Development,</i> 69, 3, 248-252\nBrown, A. (1994) <i>Groupwork.</i> (3rd ed) Aldershot: Arena\nBrown, A. and Bourne, I. (1996) <i>The Social Work Supervisor.</i> Buckingham: Open University Press\nBurgess, H., and Jackson, S. (1990) Enquiry and action learning: A new approach to social work education. <i>Social Work Education,</i> 9, 3, 3-19\nDavis, B. (2002) Group supervision as a learning laboratory for the purposeful use of self in child protection work. <i>Journal of Teaching in Social Work,</i> 22, 1/2, 183-198\nDouglas, T. (1991) <i>A Handbook of Common Groupwork Problems.</i> London: Tavistock\nEllis, M.V. and Douce, L.A. (1994) Group supervision of novice clinical supervisors: Eight recurring issues. <i>Journal of Counseling and Development,</i> 72, 5, 520-525\nFord, K. and Jones, A. (1987, <i>Student Supervision.</i> Basingstoke: Macmillan/BASW\nHillerbrand, E. (1989) Cognitive differences between experts and novices: Implications for group supervision. <i>Journal of Counseling and Development,</i> 67, 5, 293-296\nHodge, J. (1985) <i>Planning for Co-leadership.</i> Grapevine [43 Fern Ave, Newcastle-Upon-Tyne, NE2 2QU]\nHolloway, E. and Johnston, R. (1985) Group supervision: Widely practiced but poorly understood. <i>Counselor Education and Supervision,</i> 24, 332-340\nJaques, D. (2000) <i>Learning Groups.</i> (3rd ed) London: Kogan Page\nKadushin, A. (1976) <i>Supervision in Social Work.</i> New York: Columbia University Press\nKadushin, A. and Harkness, D. (2002) <i>Supervision in Social Work.</i> (4th ed) New York: Columbia University Press\nMary, N.L. and Herse, M.H. (1992) What do field seminars accomplish? Student and instructor perspectives. <i>Journal of Teaching in Social Work,</i> 6, 2, 59-73\nMason, L. (1999) A cooperative study to identify strategies for group supervision in occupational therapy fieldwork placements, <i>Occupational Therapy International,</i> 6, 3, 224-242\nMiles, M. and Hubberman, A. (1994) <i>Qualitative Data Analysis: An Expanded sourcebook.</i> London: Sage\nNichol, D. (1997) <i>Research on Learning and Higher Education Teaching,.</i> UCoSDA Briefing Paper 45. Sheffield: Universities and Colleges Staff Development Agency\nO’Dee, M. (1995) Using groupwork methods in social work education. <i>Groupwork,</i> 8, 2, 186-176\nPowles, W.E. (2000) Response to special issue on group supervision of group psychology. <i>International Journal of Group Psychotherapy,</i> 50, 2, 251-253\nPrieto, L.R. (1996) Group supervision: Still widely practiced but poorly understood. <i>Counselor Education and Supervision</i>, 35, 295-307\nRedl, F. (1951) Art of group composition. in S. Shulze (Ed) <i>Creative Living in a Children’s Institution.</i> New York: Association Press\nRosenthal, L. (1999) Group supervision of groups: a modern analytic perspective. <i>International Journal of Group Psychotherapy,</i> 49, 2, 197-213\nSales, E., and Navarre, E. (1970) <i>Individual and Group Supervision in Field Instruction: A research report.</i> Ann Arbour: University of Michigan, School of Social Work\nShulman, L. (1984) <i>The Skills of Helping: Individuals and groups</i>. (2nd ed) Ithaca, Ill: F.E. Peacock\nShulman, (1987) The hidden group in the classroom: The use of group process in teaching groupwork practice, <i>Journal of Teaching in Social Work,</i> 1, 2, Fall/Winter, 3-31\nSchutz, W.C. (1958) <i>FIRO: A Three-dimensional theory of interpersonal behaviour.</i> New York: Reinhart\nSchiller, L.Y. (1995) Stages of development in women’s groups: A relational model. in R. Kurland and R. Salmon (Eds) <i>Groupwork Practice in a Troubled Society: Problems and opportunities.</i> Binghampton, NY: Haworth Press\nSchiller, L.Y. (1997) Rethinking stages of development in women’s groups: Implications for practice. <i>Social Work with Groups,</i> 20, 3, 3-19\nSkunk, D.H. and Hanseon, A.R. (1985) Peer models: Influence on children s self-efficacy and achievement, <i>Journal of Educational Psychology</i>, 77, 313-322\nTaylor, I. (1996) Enquiry and action learning: Empowerment in social work education. in S. Jackson and M. Preston-Shoot (eds) <i>Educating Social Workers in Changing Policy Context.</i> London: Whiting Birch\nTebb, S., Manning, D.W., and Klaumann, T.K. (1996) A renaissance in group supervision in practicum, <i>The Clinical Supervisor,</i> 14, 2, 39-51\nTabathi, L.J.V. and Mamasela, S.C. (2001) A framework for the practice of group supervision. <i>Social Work/Maatskaplike Werk,</i> 37, 3, 222-230\nWalter, C.A. and Young, T.M. (1999) Combining individual and group supervision in educating for the social work profession. <i>The Clinical Supervisor,</i> 18, 2, 73-89\nWhitaker, D. S. (2001) <i>Using Groups to Help People</i>. (2nd ed) Hove: Brunner-Routledge\nYalom, I.D. (1995) <i>The Theory and Practice of Group Psychotherapy.</i> (4th ed) New York: Basic Books\n

Downloads

Published

2012-12-20

How to Cite

Lindsay, T. (2012). Group learning on social work placements. Groupwork, 15(1), 61-89. https://doi.org/10.1921/gpwk.v15i1.573

Issue

Section

Articles