The Eureka Moment? The creation of the British Welfare State

Martin Powell

doi:10.1921/swssr.v20i3.1313

Authors

Martin Powell University of Birmingham

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.1921/swssr.v20i3.1313

Abstract

This article explores when the welfare state was established in Britain. First it examines the definitions of the welfare state, before turning to outline the methods and criteria used in exploring the establishment of welfare states. It then discusses the criteria that have been applied to the British case (expenditure; legislation; content; social citizenship; antithesis of the Poor Law) before critically analysing the arguments for different creation periods for the British welfare state (Old Poor Law; nineteenth century; Liberal reforms; inter-war period; 1945; later periods). It is concluded that while the strongest case and the greatest number of dimensions suggest 1945, in the words of T H Marshall: ‘we may still be in doubt what was the exact combination of circumstances in Britain in the 1940's which evoked that cry of "Eureka !’

Author Biography

Martin Powell, University of Birmingham

Professor of Health and Social Policy and Head of the Health Services Management Centre

References

Amenta, E. (2002), ‘What we Know About The Development of Social Policy: Comparative and Historical Research in Comparative and Historical Perspective’, in J. Mahoney and D. Rueschemeyer (eds.), Comparative Historical Analysis: Achievements and Agenda. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 154–82.

Amenta, E. and Hicks, A. (2010), Research Methods in Castles, F., Leibfried, S., Lewis, J., Obinger, H. and Pierson, C. (2010, eds) The Oxford Handbook of the Welfare State, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 105-120.

Beland, D. and Petersen, K. (2014), Introduction in Beland, D. and Petersen, K. (eds, 2014) Analysing Social Policy Concepts and Language, Bristol: Policy Press, 1-11.

Blaug, M., (1964), ‘The poor law report reexamined’, J. Econ. Hist., Xxiv: 229- 243.

Block, F. and Somers, M. (2003), In the Shadow of Speenhamland: Social Policy and the Old Poor Law, Politics and Society, 31(2): 283-323.

Bonoli, G. (1997), Classifying Welfare States: a Two-dimension Approach. Journal of Social Policy, 26, pp 351-372

Briggs, A. (1961), ‘The welfare state in historical perspective’, European Journal of Sociology, 2(2): 221–58.

Bruce, M. (1968), The Coming of the Welfare State, 4th edn, London: Batsford.

Castles, F. (2002), Developing new measures of welfare state change and reform, European Journal of Political Research 41: 613–641

De Swaan, A. (1988), In Care of the State. Health Care, Education and Welfare in Europe and the USA in the Modern Era. Cambridge, UK: Polity

Esping-Andersen, G. (1990), The Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism, Cambridge: Polity Press.

Ferrera, M. (2005), The Boundaries of Welfare. European Integration and the new Spatial Politics of Social Protection. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Ferrera, M. (2008), The European Welfare State: Golden Achievements, Silver Prospects, West European Politics, 31(1-2): 82-107.

Flora, P. and Alber, J. (1981). Modernization, democratization and the development of welfare states in Western Europe, in P. Flora and A. Heidenheimer (eds) The Development of Welfare States in Europe and America, New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Books, 37-80.

Garland, D. (2014) The Welfare State: A Fundamental Dimension of Modern Government, European Journal of Sociology, 55(3): 327–364

Green-Pedersen, C. (2004), The Dependent Variable Problem within the Study of Welfare State Retrenchment, Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis: Research and Practice, 6(1): 3-14.

Heidenheimer, A. (1981), Education and social security entitlements in Europe and America. In P. Flora and A. Heidenheimer (eds) The Development of Welfare States in Europe and America, New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Books, 269-305.

Hicks, A. (1999), Social Democracy and Welfare Capitalism, Ithaca: Cornell University Press.

I.L.O. (1950) International Labour Conference, 34th Session, ‘Objectives and Minimum Standards of Social Security’.

Jones, M. and Lowe, R. (2002), From Beveridge to Blair. The First Fifty Years of Britain’s Welfare State 1948-98, Manchester: Manchester University Press.

Kim, K-s (2001), Determinants of the timing of social insurance legislation among 18 OECD countries, Int J Soc Welfare, 10: 2–13

King, D. and Waldron, J. (1988), Citizenship, Social Citizenship and the Defence of Welfare Provision, B.J.Pol.S. 18: 415-443.

Kuhnle, S. and Sander, A. (2010), The emergence of the Western Welfare State in Castles, F., Leibfried, S., Lewis, J., Obinger, H. and Pierson, C. (2010, eds) The Oxford handbook of the Welfare State, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 61-80.

Lambert, R. (1962.) A Victorian National Health Service: State Vaccination 1855-7, Historical Journal, V: 1, 1-8.

Lindert, P. (1994), The rise of social spending, 1880–1930, Explorations in Economic History, 31: 1– 37.

Lowe, R. (1993), The Welfare State in Britain since 1945, Basingstoke: Macmillan.

Marshall, T. H. (1961), The Welfare State: A Sociological Interpretation, European Journal of Sociology, 2(2): 284-300.

Marshall, T.H. (1963), Sociology at the Crossroads, London, Heinemann.

Marshall, T. H. (1975),Social Policy, London.

Marwick, A. (1967), The Labour party and the welfare state in Britain 1900-1948, American Historical Review, 73(2): 380-403.

Marx, K. and F. Engels. (1966), Selected Works in Three Volumes, Moscow.

Orloff, A. S., and Skocpol, T. (1984), Why Not Equal Protection? Explaining the Politics of Public Social Spending in Britain, 1900-1911, and the United States, 1880s-1920, American Sociological Review: 726–50.

Petersen, K. and Petersen, J. (2013), Confusion and divergence: origins and meanings of the term ‘welfare state’ in Germany and Britain, 1840-1940, Journal of European Social Policy, 23(1): 1-15.

Pierson, C. (2004), Late Industrializers and the Development of the Welfare State, Social Policy and Development Programme, United Nations Research Institute for Social Development.

Pierson, C. (2006), Beyond the Welfare State? 3rd edn. Polity Press, Cambridge.

Pierson, P. (1998), Irresistible Forces, Immovable Objects: Post-industrial Welfare States Confront Permanent Austerity, Journal of European Public Policy, 5: 539–60.

Powell, M. (2002), The Hidden History of Social Citizenship, Citizenship Studies, 6(3): 229-244.

Powell, M. and Hewitt, M. (2002), Welfare State and Welfare Change, Buckingham: Open University Press.

Roberts, D. (1960), Victorian Origins of the Welfare State, New Haven: Yale University Press.

Saville, J. (1957-8), The welfare state: an historical approach, New Reasoner, 3,

Solar P. (1995). Poor relief and English economic development before the Industrial Revolution. Econ Hist Rev, 48: 1–22.

Somers, M. and Block, F. (2005), From Poverty to Perversity: Ideas, Markets, and Institutions over 200 Years of Welfare Debate, American Sociological Review, 70:260–287.

Szreter, S., Kinmonth, A, Kriznik, N., and Kelly, M. (2016), The art of medicine Health, welfare, and the state—the dangers of forgetting history, Lancet, 388 December 3,, 2734-5.

Temple, W. (1941), Citizen and Churchman, London: MacMillan.

Temple, W. (1942). Christianity and the Social Order, London: Penguin.

Thane, P. (1982), Foundations of the Welfare State, London: Longman.

Therborn, G. (1983), “When, how and why does a state become a welfare state?” Presented at the ECPR Joint Workshops in Freiburg, March 20-25.

Therborn, G. (1984), Classes and states: Welfare State developments, 1881-1981. Studies in Political Economy, 14.

Tomlinson, J. (1998), Why so Austere? The British Welfare State of the 1940s, Journal of Social Policy, 27(1): 63–77.

Van Bavel, B. and Rijpma, A (2015), How important were formalized charity and social spending before the rise of the welfare state? A long-run analysis of selected western European cases, 1400–1850, Economic History Review, 1-29.

Veit-Wilson, J. (2000), States of welfare: a conceptual challenge, Social Policy and Administration, 34(1): 1–25.

Wincott, D. (2001), Reassessing the Social Foundations of Welfare (State) Regimes’, New Political Economy, 6(3): 409–25.

Wincott, D. (2011), Images of welfare in law and society: the British welfare state in comparative perspective, Journal of Law and Society, 38(3): 343-75.

Wincott, D. (2013). The (golden) age of the welfare state: interrogating a conventional wisdom, Public Administration, 91(4): 806–822.

Wincott, D. (2014), Original and imitated or elusive and limited? Towards a genealogy of the welfare state idea in Britain, in Beland, D. and Petersen, K. (eds, 2014) Analysing Social Policy Concepts and Language, Bristol: Policy Press, 127-141.

Woodroffe, K. (1968), The making of the welfare state in England, Journal of Social History, 1(4): 303-324.