Exploring models of D/deaf service user involvement in translating quality standards into local practice

Authors

  • Alys Young
  • Ros Hunt
  • Hugh McLaughlin

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.1921/swssr.v12i3.457

Keywords:

<i>deaf</i>, <i>hard of hearing</i>, <i>BSL</i>, <i>best practice standards</i>, <i>service user involvement</i>

Abstract

This article concerns the participation of service user groups in the translation of social work standards into social work practices. The context is a development and research project about quality standards in adult social services with Deaf and hard of hearing people. The project was set up both to support effective changes in local working practices, as well as to study the processes underlying those changes. Central to these processes had to be the engagement of local service user groups of Deaf or hard of hearing people. Specifically this article analyses three differing styles of engagement between providers and users involved in the project. We have termed these: a coworker model; a rights-based model; and a politically aware model. It explores the consequences for developmental action of these styles and the extent to which what is achieved, not just how it is achieved can be attributed to the manner of engagement. The role of locally contingent conditions as adequate explanation for different kinds of service user/service provider involvement is also considered. The article contributes to the wider debate of how to turn user rights-in-theory into user rights-in-practice, through an analytical focus on the structuring of provider/user engagement when there is an overt agenda of service improvement in line with pre-established standards.

References

Association of Directors of Social Services, Local Government Authority, Royal National Institute for Deaf People and British Deaf Association (1999) <i>Best Practice Standards in Social Work with Deaf and Hard of Hearing People</i>. London: RNID\nBalloch, S. and Taylor, M. (2001) Introduction. in S. Balloch and M. Taylor <i>Partnership Working: Policy and practice</i>. Bristol: The Policy Press\nBeresford, P. (2001) Service users, social policy and the future of welfare. <i>Critical Social Policy</i> 21, 4, 494-512\nBeresford, P. and Croft, S. (1993) <i>Citizen Involvement: A practical guide for change</i>. London: Macmillan\nBiehal, N. (1993). Changing practice: participation, rights and community care. <i>British Journal of Social Work</i>, 23, 5, 443-458\nBraye, S. (2000) Participation and involvement in social care: An overview. in H. Kemshall, R. Littlechild (Eds.) <i>User Involvement and Participation in Social Care Research Informing Practice</i>. London: Jessica Kingsley (pp.9-28)\nBraye, S. and Preston-Shoot, M (1995). <i>Empowering Practice in Social Care</i>. Buckingham: Open University Press\nCharlton, J.I. (2000) <i>Nothing About US Without Us: Disability, oppression and empowerment</i>. Berkeley: University of California Press\nDepartment of Health (1997) <i>A Service on the Edge. Inspection of services for deaf and hard of hearing people</i>. London: Department of Health\nDepartment of Health (1998) <i>Modernising Social Services: Promoting independence, improving protection, raising standards</i>. London: The Stationery Office\nDepartment of Health (1999) <i>Stepping Away from the Edge. Improving service for Deaf and hard of hearing people</i>. Available at <a target="_blank" href='http://doh/gov/uk/scg/steppingaway.htm'>doh/gov/uk/scg/steppingaway.htm</a>\nEdge of Change (2004) <i>Edge of Change Project Practice Resources and Site Reports</i>. (CDRom) London: RNID\nHarris, J. and Bamford, C. (2001) The uphill struggle. Services for Deaf and hard of hearing people: Issues of equality, participation and access. <i>Disability and Society</i> 16, 7, 969-979\nHawcroft, L., Peckford, B. and Thomson A. (1996) <i>Visible Voices</i>. Carlisle: BDA\nMcIver, S. (1994) <i>Obtaining the View of Black Users of Health Services</i>. London: Kings Fund Centre\nMcLaughlin, H. (2004) Partnership: panacea of pretence? <i>Journal of Interprofessional Care</i>, 18 2, 103–113\nMcLaughlin, H., Brown, D. and Young, A.M. (2004) Consultation, community and empowerment: Lessons from the Deaf community. <i>The Journal of Social Work</i>, 4, 2, 153-165\nMcLaughlin, H., Young, A., and Hunt, R. (2005 under review) Edging the Change: Action research with social workers and Deaf and hard of hearing service users to achieve ‘Best Practice Standards’ <i>The Journal of Social Work</i>\nMorgan, J. (1992) <i>Getting to the Core: A practical guide to understanding users’ experience in the health services</i>. Shropshire: Shropshire Health Authority\nMorris, J. (1997) <i>Community Care: Working in partnership with service users</i>. Birmingham: Venture Press\nMullender, A., Ward, D. (1991) <i>Self-Directed Groupwork: Users take action for empowerment</i>. London: Whiting and Birch\nParratt, D. (1995) Working with Deaf people. <i>Disability and Society</i> 10, 501-519\nUKCoD (2001) <i>Setting Up a Deaf Users’ Forum</i>. London: UKCoD\nStevenson, O. and Parsloe, P. (1993) <i>Community Care and Empowerment</i>. York: Joseph Rowntree Foundation\nYoung, A.M. (2006) The Experience of Deafness: Psycho-social effects. in V. Newton, (Ed.) <i>Deafness and Tropical Disease</i>. London: Whurr\nYoung, A.M., Hunt, R., McLaughlin, H. and Mello-Baron, S. (2004a) <i>Edge of Change (Final Report)</i>. London: RNID\nYoung, A.M., Hunt, R. and McLaughlin, H. (2004b) <i>Edge of Change Project Research Summary in British Sign Language</i>. London: RNID,\nYoung, A.M., Hunt, R., Loosemore-Reppen, G., McLaughlin, H. and Mello-Baron, S. (2004) A profile of 15 social work services with deaf and hard of hearing people in England. <i>Research, Policy and Planning</i>, 22, 1, 31–46\n

Downloads

Published

2012-12-26

How to Cite

Young, A., Hunt, R., & McLaughlin, H. (2012). Exploring models of D/deaf service user involvement in translating quality standards into local practice. Social Work and Social Sciences Review, 12(3), 25-39. https://doi.org/10.1921/swssr.v12i3.457