Step forward? Step back? The professionalisation of fostering
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1921/swssr.v13i1.465Keywords:
professionalisation, foster care, family, work, genderAbstract
This article examines the long term if uneven trend towards professionalisation in foster care, within the contexts of theoretical debates on professionalisation and contemporary policy in relation to looked after children. While the professionalising trend has been driven by a number of powerful factors within foster care and by broader societal and policy developments, it remains contentious due to the hybrid nature of foster care straddling the domains of ‘family’ and ‘work’. Various aspects of hybridity are explored including its implications for motivation, training and differentiation among foster carers. While broadly supporting the professionalisation of foster carers, not least as a measure to tackle their exploitation and its gendered nature, it is argued that hybridity requires a delicate balance to be struck and maintained in order that further professionalising measures do not undermine the personal and familial aspects of foster care that are crucial to its success.
References
Adamson, G. (1973) <i>The Care-Takers.</i> London: Bookstall\nAldridge, M. and Evetts, J. (2003) Rethinking the concept of professionalism: The case of journalism, <i>British Journal of Sociology,</i> 54, 4, 547-64\n<b>Beresford, P. and Croft, S. (2001) Service users’ knowledges and the social construction of social work.</b><i>Journal of Social Work</i>, 1, 3, 295-316\nBerridge D. and Cleaver, H. (1987) <i>Foster Home Breakdown.</i> Oxford: Blackwell\nBostock, L. (2003) <i>Childminding Registration and Private Fostering.</i> Bristol: Social Care Institute for Excellence\nBroad, B. (2001) <i>Kinship Care: The placement choice for children and young people.</i> Lyme Regis: Russell House\nBrewer, C. and Lait, J. (1980) <i>Can Social Work Survive?</i> London: Temple Smith\nCaesar, G., Parchment, M and Berridge, D. (1994) <i>Black Perspectives on Services for Children in Need.</i> Barkingside, Essex: Barnardos/National Children's Bureau\nCameron, C., Candappa, M., McQuail, S., Mooney, A., Moss, P and Petrie, P. (2003) <i>Early Years and Childcare International Evidence Project.</i> London: Thomas Coram Research Unit\nCameron, C. and Boddy, J. (2006) Knowledge and education for care workers: What do they need to know?. in J. Boddy, C. Cameron and P. Moss <i>Care Work: Present and future.</i> London: Routledge\nCampbell, M. (2005) <i>Integrated and Qualified: Workforce development for effective delivery of services to vulnerable children and young people and those who care for them. Policy drivers update.</i> Leeds: Skills for Care\nChamberlain, P. and Reid, J. (1998) Comparison of two community alternatives to incarceration, for chronic juvenile offenders. <i>Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology,</i> 66, 4, 624-33\nChief Secretary to the Treasury (2003) <i>Every Child Matters.</i> Cm5860. London: TSO\nChildren Now (2006) News. 27 September, p.4\nClarke, J. and Newman, J. (1997) <i>The Managerial State: Power, politics and ideology in the remaking of social welfare.</i> London: Sage\nCleaver, H. (2000) <i>Fostering Family Contact.</i> London: TSO\nCommission for Social Care Inspection (2006) <i>The State of Social Care 2005-6.</i> London: Commission for Social Care Inspection\nColton, M. and Williams, M. (Eds.) (2006) <i>Global Perspectives on Foster Family Care</i>. Lyme Regis: Russell House\nCorrick, H. (1999) The professionalisation of foster care. in A. Wheal <i>The RHP Companion to Foster Care</i>. Lyme Regis: Russell House\nDaly, M. and Lewis, J. (2003) The concept of social care and the analysis of contemporary welfare states. <i>British Journal of Sociology</i>, 51, 2, 281-298\nDepartment for Education and Skills (2006a) <i>Statistics of Education: Children looked after by local authorities year ending 31 march 2005. Volume 1: National tables.</i> London: Department for Education and Skills\nDepartment for Education and Skills (2006b) <i>Care Matters: Transforming the lives of children and young people in care. (Cm 6932).</i> London: Department for Education and Skills\nDepartment of Health (2002) <i>Fostering Services: National Minimum Standards, Fostering Services Regulations.</i> London: TSO\nDinnage, R. and Kelmer Pringle, M. (1967) <i>Foster Home Care, Facts and fallacies: A review of research in the United States, Western Europe, Israel and Great Britain between 1948 and 1966</i>. London: Longmans\nEtzioni, A. (1969) <i>Semi-Professions and their Organisation: Teachers, nurses and social workers.</i> New York: Free Press\nFarmer, E., Moyers, S. and Lipscombe, J. (2004) <i>Fostering Adolescents.</i> London: Jessica Kingsley\nFarmer, E. and Moyers, S. (2005) Children Placed with Family and Friends: Placement patterns and outcomes. Briefing. <a target="_blank" href='http://www.bristol.ac.uk/sps/downloads/Hadley/kinship%20care.doc'>www.bristol.ac.uk/sps/downloads/Hadley/kinship%20care.doc</a>\nFawcett, B., Featherstone, B., and Goddard, J (2004) <i>Contemporary Child Care: Policy and practice</i>. Basingstoke: Palgrave\nFolbre, N. and Nelson, J. (2000) For love or money: Or both?. <i>Journal of Economic Perspectives,</i> 14, 4, 123–40\nFostering Network (2004) <i>Survey of Carers</i>. London: Fostering Network\nFoster, P. and Wilding, P. (2000) Whither welfare professionalism? <i>Social Policy and Adminisration,</i> 34, 2, 143-59\nFournier, V. (1999) The appeal to ‘professionalism’ as a disciplinary mechanism. <i>Sociological Review</i>, 47, 2, 280-307\nFreidson, E. (1988) <i>Professional Powers: A study in the institutionalisation of formal knowledge.</i> Chicago: Chicago University Press\nGiddens, A. (1998) <i>Third Way: The renewal of social democracy.</i> Cambridge: Polity\nGillen, S. (2004) Court action will test discriminatory fostering payments to kinship carers. <i>Community Care</i>, 4th March, pp.18-19\nGillies, V. (2005) Meeting Parents’ needs? Discourses of ‘support’ and ‘inclusion’ in family policy. <i>Critical Social Policy</i>, 25, 1, 70-90\nHarris, J. (2002) <i>The Social Work Business.</i> London: Routledge\nHayden, C., Goddard, J., Gorin, S., and van der Spek, N. (1999) <i>State Child Care: Looking after children?.</i> London: Jessica Kingsley\nHazel, N., (1981) <i>A Bridge to Independence</i>. Oxford: Basil Blackwell\nHealy, K. and Meagher, G. (2004) The reprofessionalization of social work: Collaborative approaches for achieving professional recognition. <i>British Journal of Social Work</i>, 34, 2, 243-60\nHearn, J. (1982) Notes on patriarchy, professionalisation and the semi-professions. <i>Sociology</i>, 16, 2, 184-202\nHenderson, J. and Forbat, L. (2002) Relationship-based social policy: personal and policy constructions of ‘care’. <i>Critical Social Policy</i>, 22, 4, 669-687\nHenricson, C. (2003) <i>Government and Parenting: Is there a case for a policy review and a parents’ code.</i> York: Joseph Rowntree Foundation\nHM Revenue and Customs (2005) <i>Foster Care Relief.</i> <a target="_blank" href='http://www.hmrc.gov.uk/individuals/foster-care-relief.pdf'>www.hmrc.gov.uk/individuals/foster-care-relief.pdf</a>\nHochschild, A. (1983) <i>The Managed Heart: Commercialisation of human feelings.</i> Berkely: University of California Press\nHolman, R. (1975) The place of fostering in social work. <i>British Journal of Social Work,</i> 5, 1, 3-29\nHowe, D. (1986) <i>Social Workers and their Practice in Welfare Bureaucracies.</i> Aldershot: Gower\nHudson, J. (1999) Summary. in A. Wheal <i>The RHP Companion to Foster Care</i>. Lyme Regis: Russell House\nHugman, R. (1991) <i>Power in Caring Professions.</i> Basingstoke: Macmillan\nIllich, I. (1977) <i>Disabling Professions.</i> London: Marion Boyars\nJohnson, T. (1972) <i>Power and Professions.</i> London: Macmillan\nKendrick, A. (1998) In their best interest? Protecting children from abuse in residential and foster care. <i>International Journal of Child and Family Welfare</i>, 3, 2, 169-185\nKirk, S. and Glendinning, C. (2002) Supporting ‘expert’ parents: Professional support and families caring for a child with complex health care needs in the community, <i>International Journal of Nursing Studies,</i> 39, 6, 625-635\nKirton, D. (2001) Family budgets and public money: spending fostering payments. <i>Child and Family Social Work,</i> 6, 4, 305-314\nKirton, D., Beecham, J. and Ogilvie, K. (2003) <i>Remuneration and Performance in Foster Care.</i> Canterbury: University of Kent\nLand, H. (2002) Spheres of care in the UK: separate and unequal, <i>Critical Social Policy</i>, 22, 1, 13-22\nLarson, M.S. (1977) <i>The Rise of Professionalism: A sociological analysis.</i> Berkely: University of California Press\nLowe, K.(1999) Training for foster carers. in A. Wheal <i>The RHP Companion to Foster Care</i>. Lyme Regis: Russell House\nMacDonald, K. (1995) <i>The Sociology of the Professions.</i> London: Sage\nMacdonald, G. and Kakavelakis, I. (2004) <i>Helping Foster Carers to Manage Challenging Behaviour: Evaluation of a cognitive-behavioural training programme for foster carers.</i> Exeter: University of Exeter, Centre for Evidence-based Social Services\nMeyer, M.H. (2000) <i>Care Work: Gender, labor and the welfare state.</i> New York: Routledge\nMiller, P. and Rose, N. (1990) Governing economic life. <i>Economy and Society,</i> 19, 1, 1-31\nMinnis, H. and Devine, C. (2001) The effect of foster carer training on the emotional and behavioural functioning of looked after children. <i>Adoption and Fostering,</i> 25, 1, 44-54\nMoore, W. (1970 <i>The Professions: Roles and rules</i>. New York: Russell Sage Foundation\nNational Foster Care Association (1989) <i>Foster Care Charter.</i> London: National Foster Care Association\nNational Foster Care Association (1993) <i>Foster Carers: Payment for skills.</i> London: National Foster Care Association\nNational Foster Care Association (1997) <i>Foster Care in Crisis: A call to professionalise the forgotten service</i>. London: National Foster Care Association\nNelson, J. (1999) Of markets and martyrs: Is it ok to pay well for care?. <i>Feminist Economics,</i> 5, 3, 43-59\nNixon, S. (1997) The limits of support in foster care. <i>British Journal of Social Work</i>, 27, 6, 913-930\nNutt, L. (2006) <i>The Lives of Foster Carers: Private sacrifices, public restrictions.</i> Abingdon: Routledge\nO’Brien, V. (2000) Relative care. in G. Kelly and R. Gilligan <i>Issues in Foster Care: Policy, practice and research</i>, London: Jessica Kingsley\nOldfield, N. (1997) <i>The Adequacy of Foster Care Allowances.</i> Aldershot: Ashgate\nPahl, J. (1989) <i>Money and Marriage.</i> Basingstoke: Macmillan\nParker, R. (1966) <i>Decision in Child Care: A study of prediction in fostering</i>. London: Allen and Unwin\nParry, J., Taylor, R., Pettinger, L., and Glucksmann, M. (2005) Confronting the challenges of work today: New horizons and perspectives. <i>Sociological Review</i>, 53, s2, 1-18\nPearson, G. (1983) <i>Hooligan: A history of respectable ideas.</i> London: Macmillan\nPithouse, A., Hill-Tout, J. and Lowe, K. (2002) Training foster carers in challenging behaviour: A case study in disappointment?. <i>Child and Family Social Work,</i> 7, 3, 203-214\nRhodes, P. (1993) Charitable vocation or ‘proper job’?: The role of payment in foster care. <i>Adoption and Fostering</i>, 17, 1, 8-13\nSchofield, G., Beek, M., and Sargent, K. with Thoburn, J. (2000) <i>Growing Up in Foster Care.</i> London: British Agencies for Adoption and Fostering\nSellick, C. (2002) The aims and principles of independent fostering agencies: A view from the inside. <i>Adoption and Fostering</i>, 26, 1, 56-63\nSellick, C. and Connolly, J. (2002) Independent fostering agencies uncovered: The findings of a national study. <i>Child and Family Social Work</i>, 7, 1, 107-120\nSellick, C. and Howell, D. (2003) <i>Innovative, Tried and Tested: A review of good practice in fostering.</i> London: Social Care Institute for Excellence\nSergeant, H. (2006) <i>Handle With Care: An investigation into the care system.</i> London: Centre for Young Policy Studies\nShaw, M. and Hipgrave, T. (1983) <i>Specialist Fostering</i>, London: Batsford\nSinclair, I. and Wilson, K. (2003) Matches and mismatches: The contribution of carers and children to the success of foster placements. <i>British Journal of Social Work,</i> 33, 7, 871-884\nSinclair, I, Gibbs, I., and Wilson, K. (2004) <i>Foster Carers: Why they stay and why they go.</i> London: Jessica Kingsley\nSinclair, I, Gibbs, I. and Wilson, K. (2005) <i>Foster Placements: Why they succeed and why they fail.</i> London: Jessica Kingsley\nSmith, B. (1988) Something you do for love: The question of money and foster care. <i>Adoption and Fostering</i>, 12, 4, 34-38\nStone, D. (2000) Caring by the book. in M.H. Meyer <i>Care Work: Gender, Labor and the Welfare State.</i> New York: Routledge\nSwain, V. (2007) <i>Can't Afford to Foster: A survey of fee payments to foster carers.</i> London: Fostering Network\nTapsfield, R. (2001) Kinship care: A family rights group perspective. in B. Broad <i>Kinship Care: The placement choice for children and young people.</i> Lyme Regis: Russell House\nTapsfield, R. and Collier, F. (2005) <i>The Cost of Foster Care: Investing in</i> our <i>children's future.</i> London: British Agencies for Adoption and Fostering/The Fostering Network\nTesta, M. and Rolock, N. (1999) Professional foster care: A future worth pursuing? <i>Child Welfare,</i> 78, 1, 108-124\nToren, N. (1972) <i>Social Work: The case of a semi-profession.</i> London: Sage\nTriseliotis, J., Sellick C. and Short, R. (1995) <i>Foster Care: Theory and practice.</i> London: Batsford/British Agencies for Adoption and Fostering\nTriseliotis, J., Borland, M., and Hill, M. (2000) <i>Delivering Foster Care,</i> London: British Agencies for Adoption and Fostering\nUK Joint Working Party on Foster Care (1999) <i>UK National Standards for Foster Care</i>. London: National Foster Care Association\nVerity, P. (1999) Financial matters. in A. Wheal <i>The RHP Companion to Foster Care</i>. Lyme Regis: Russell House\nWaterhouse, S. (1997) <i>The Organisation of Fostering Services: A study of the arrangements for the delivery of fostering services in England</i>. London: National Foster Care Association\nWaterhouse, S. (2001) Keeping children in kinship placements within court proceedings. in B. Broad <i>Kinship Care: The placement choice for children and young people.</i> Lyme Regis: Russell House\nWheal, A. (1999) Family and friends who are carers. in A. Wheal <i>The RHP Companion to Foster Care</i>. Lyme Regis: Russell House\nWilensky, H. (1964) Professionalisation of everyone, <i>American Journal of Sociology,</i> 70, 2, 137-58\nWilson, K. and Evetts, J. (2006) The professionalisation of foster care. <i>Adoption and Fostering,</i> 30, 1, 39-47\nWitz, A. (1992) <i>Professions and Patriarchy.</i> London: Routledge\nZelizer, V. (1997) <i>The Social Meaning of Money: Pin money, pay checks, poor relief and other currencies.</i> Princeton: Princeton University Press\n
Downloads
Published
2012-12-20
How to Cite
Kirton, D. (2012). Step forward? Step back? The professionalisation of fostering. Social Work and Social Sciences Review, 13(1), 6-24. https://doi.org/10.1921/swssr.v13i1.465
Issue
Section
Articles
License
Copyright lies with the journal. Enquiries regarding reproduction should be sent in the first place to enquiries@whitingbirch.net
