Creativity, fantasy, role-play and theatre in social work
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1921/swssr.v13i3.476Keywords:
<i>science war</i>, <i>quantitative studies</i>, <i>evidence based science</i>, <i>forum theatre</i>, <i>binding fantasy</i>, <i>phronetic social science</i>, <i>actual science</i>, <i>user involvement</i>Abstract
This article considers the development of social work research and social work practice. In contrast to the usual emphasis on evidence based studies and tools in social work research the article argues for the development of quantitative studies and tools and proposes creativity, fantasy, role-play and especially Forum Theatre as key elements of this development. This approach is compatible with Flyberg's 2002 concept of ‘actual science’ – a context-dependent methodology oriented more towards subjects than objects – or ‘phronetic social science’ – where judgements and decisions are based on values. Both approaches have the capacity to incorporate the complexity of social work, to involving users and social workers in research processes, and to build up knowledge production from the bottom up. The article also argues that creativity, role-play, fantasy and Forum theatre are as necessary and useful in developing social work practice as in facilitating the research process.
References
Angel, B.Ø. (2003) Evidensbaserede programmer – kunnskapsformer og menneskesyn i sosialt arbeit [Evidence-based programs – forms of knowledge and view of human nature in social work], <i>Nordisk Sosialt Arbeit</i>, 23, 2, 66-72 <a target="_blank" href='http://hsr.e-contentmanagement.com/11.1/11-1p79.htm'>http://hsr.e-contentmanagement.com/11.1/11-1p79.htm</a>\nBlackburn, J. et al. (2004) <i>Evidence-Based Social Work Practice – Ethical Issues and Considerations</i>. Presentation at IFSW Global Social Work Conference, Adelaide Convention Centre, South Australia\nBørner, T. (2005) Effekt eller defekt – om behovet for evaluering på det sociale område [Effect or defect – concerning needs of evaluation within the social field], <i>Social Forskning</i>, 4, 8-9 <a target="_blank" href='http://www.blackwell-synergy.com/doi/pdf/10.1111/j.1468-2850.1998.tb00157.x?cookieSet=1'>http://www.blackwell-synergy.com/doi/pdf/10.1111/j.1468-2850.1998.tb00157.x?cookieSet=1</a>\nDenvall, V. (2005) Evidensbaseret socialt arbejde – fra evidens viden til vidensbaseret praksis? [Evidence-based social work – from evidence knowledge to knowledge based practice?], <i>Metodemagasinet</i>, 7, 26-27\nEjler, N., Nielsen, S.B. and Petersen, C.E. (2004) <i>Undersøgelse af retssikkerhedslovens § 4</i>. [<i>Investigation of the Consolidation Act on Legal Protection and Administration in Social matters section 4</i>] Copenhagen: Danish Ministry of Social Affairs\nEkeland, T. (2005) Kvalitetssikring eller instrumentalistisk fejlgreb [Quality-protection or instrumentalistic mistake], <i>Social Kritik</i>, 102, 34-47\nFisher, M. (2005) <i>Knowledge Production for Social Welfare: Enhancing the evidence base</i>, Key-note presentation and paper at 2005 Conference ‘Reconstructing Social Work – Critical Issues for Knowledge in Practice’, University of Helsinki\nFlyvbjerg, B. (1991) <i>Rationalitet og Magt</i>. [<i>Rationality and Power</i>] Copenhagen: Akademisk Forlag\nFlyvbjerg, B. (2001) <i>Making Social Science Matter: Why social inquiry fails and how it can succeed again</i>. New York: Cambridge University Press\nFook, J. (2005) <i>How do social workers use knowledge?</i> Key-note presentation at 2005 Conference ‘Reconstructing Social Work – Critical Issues for Knowledge in Practice’, University of Helsinki\nHansson, J. (2003) Om en kundskapsbaserad socialtjänst. [Concerning knowledge-based department of social services] <i>Nordisk Sosialt Arbeit</i>, 23, 4, 194-200\nHunter, E. and Tsey, K. (2002) Indigenous health and the contribution of sociology: A review. <i>Health Sociology Review</i>, 11, 1-2, (see http://hsr.e-contentmanagement.com/11.1/11-1p79.htm)\nHutchinson, G.S. and Oltedal, S. (2006) <i>Modeller i Sosialt Arbeit</i> [<i>Models in social work</i>], Oslo: Universitetsforlaget\nLøchen, Y. (1993) <i>Forpliktende Fantasi</i> [<i>Binding Fantacy</i>] Oslo: Universitetsforlaget\nMånsson, S. (2000) Kunskapsutveckling inom socialtjänsten och den akademiska forskningen – drar vi åt samma håll? [Knowledge development within the department of social services and academic research – are we drawing at the same direction] <i>Socionomen</i>, 8, 4-9\nMånsson, S. (2001) Nationellt stöd för kunskapsutvecklingen inom socialtjänsten. [The National support for knowledge development in the department of social services] <i>Socionomen</i>, 3, 18-20\nNissen, M.A. (2005) <i>Arbejdspapirer til Det Sociale Indikatorprojekt 2005</i>. [<i>Working papers for the Social Indicator Project 2005</i>] Århus: Århus County, Quality Department\nNielsen, S.B. and Uggerhøj, L. (2005) Mellem nærhed og magt. [Between intimacy and power] in Munch, A. (Ed.) <i>Forskning og Socialt Arbejde med Udsatte Børn og Unge: En antologi</i>. [<i>Research And Social Work with Children And Adolescents: An anthology</i>] Juelsminde: UFC Børn og Unge\nOlesen, S.P. (2004) En kommentar vedrørende evidensbaseret socialt arbejde. [A comment concerning evidence-based social work], <i>FORSA Information</i>, 4, 10, 9-10\nParloff, M.B. (1998) Is psychotherapy more than manual labour? <i>Clinical Psychology: Science and Practice</i>, 5, 3, 376-381 (see also http://www.blackwell-synergy.com/doi/pdf/10.1111/j.1468-2850.1998.tb00157.x?cookieSet=1)\nPaterson, D.L. (1995) Theatre of the Oppressed Workshops. (see <a target="_blank" href='http://www.wwcd.org/action/Boal.html'>http://www.wwcd.org/action/Boal.html)</a>\nPayne, M. (2005) <i>Modern Social Work Theory</i> (3rd ed.), New York: Palgrave Macmillan\nShaw, I. (2005) <i>Critical Social Science and Practice Research</i>,.Key-note presentation and paper at 2005 Conference ‘Reconstructing Social Work – Critical Issues for Knowledge in Practice’, University of Helsinki\nSheldon, B. et al (2005) A pre-post empirical study of obstacles to, and opportunities for evidence-based practice in social care. in A. Bilson (Ed.) <i>Evidence-Based Practice in Social Work</i>. London: Whiting & Birch\nTengvald, K. (2005) <i>Perspectives on National Knowledge Production Programs</i>. Key-note presentation at 2005 Conference ‘Reconstructing Social Work – Critical Issues for Knowledge in Practice’, University of Helsinki\nTengvald, K. (2001) Nationellt stöd för kunskapsutvecklingen inom socialtjänsten. [The national support for knowledge development in the department of social services] <i>Socionomen</i>, 3, 20-21\nUggerhøj, L. (1996) <i>Hjælp eller Afhængighed</i>. [<i>Help or Dependence</i>] Aalborg: Aalborg Universitetsforlag\n
Downloads
Published
2012-12-20
How to Cite
Uggerhøj, L. (2012). Creativity, fantasy, role-play and theatre in social work. Social Work and Social Sciences Review, 13(3), 48-62. https://doi.org/10.1921/swssr.v13i3.476
Issue
Section
Articles
License
Copyright lies with the journal. Enquiries regarding reproduction should be sent in the first place to enquiries@whitingbirch.net
