Assessment of fieldwork practice

Authors

  • Judith Knight

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.1921/jpts.v5i1.298

Keywords:

fieldwork practice, assessment, students’ experience, supervision

Abstract

Assessment of fieldwork is common to all occupational therapy courses. This form of competency based assessment has been researched across many healthcare professions. Work on the appraisal of fieldwork assessments used by occupational therapy courses in the United Kingdom is just beginning. At the present time there appears a gap in information concerning the experience of fieldwork assessment from the student’s perspective. This article seeks to address this by reporting the findings of a qualitative study of third year undergraduate occupational therapy students at University College Northampton to investigate their experience of being assessed on fieldwork.

The results showed that students expressed high levels of acceptance with the primary fieldwork assessment, the fieldwork profile. However they displayed some concern about its reliability. A major influence on the assessment process was seen to be the fieldwork educator and the supervisory relationship. In general older students appeared to have a greater degree of control over both the assessment process and the supervisory relationship. As a result of the study it would appear that a national exploration of the assessments used to assess competence of occupational therapy graduates could be beneficial to the profession.

References

Alexander, H. (1996) Physiotherapy student clinical education: The influence of subjective judgements on observational assessment. <i>Assessment and Evaluation in Higher Education</i>, 22, 4, 357-366\nAlsop, A. (1993) The developmental model of skill acquisition in fieldwork. <i>British Journal of Occupational Therapy</i>, 56, 1, 7-12\nAlsop, A., Ryan, S. (1996) <i>Making the most of fieldwork education</i>. London: Chapman Hall.\nBennett, Y. (1993) The Validity and Reliability of Assessments and Self-Assessments of Work Based Learning. <i>Assessment and Evaluation in Higher Education</i>. 18, 2, 83-93\nBonello, M. 2001) Fieldwork within the Context of Higher Education: a Literature Review. <i>British Journal of Occupational Therapy</i>, 64, 2, 93-99\nBowling, A. (2002) <i>Research Methods in Health</i>. Buckingham: Open University Press\nBrown, G.D. (1993) Accounting for power: Nurse teacher and students’ perceptions of power in their relationship. <i>Nurse Education Today</i>, 13, 111-120\nBrown, S. and Knight, P. (1994) <i>Assessing Learning in Higher Education</i>. London: Kogan Page\nBurrows, E. (1989) Clinical practice: An approach to the assessment of clinical competencies. <i>British Journal of Occupational Therapy</i>, 52, 6, 222-226\nCarpenter, C. (2000) Exploring the lived experience of disability. in K.W. Hammemell, C. Carpenter and I. Dyck (Eds) <i>Using Qualitative Research: A practical introduction for occupational and physical therapists</i>. London: Churchill Livingstone\nChambers, M. (1998) Some issues in the assessment of clinical practice: A review of the literature. <i>Journal of Clinical Nursing</i>, 7, 201-208\nChristie, B., Joyce, P. and Moeller, P. (1985) Fieldwork experience. Part II: The supervisor’s dilemma. <i>American Journal of Occupational Therapy</i>, 39, 10, 675-681\nCoates, V., Chambers, M. (1992) Evaluation of tools to assess clinical competence. <i>Nurse Education Today</i>, 12, 122-129\nCohn, E.S., Frum, D.C. (1988) Fieldwork supervision: More education is warranted. <i>American Journal of Occupational Therapy</i>, 42, 5, 325-327\nCreswell, J.W. (1998). <i>Qualitative Inquiry and Research Design: Choosing among five traditions</i>. London: Sage\nCrist, P. and Cooper, R (1988) Evaluating clinical competence with the new fieldwork evaluation. <i>American Journal of Occupational Therapy</i>, 42, 12, 771-773\nCrofts, F. (1991) Why a degree? <i>British Journal of Occupational Therapy</i>, 54, 10, 377-78\nCross, V. (1995) Perceptions of the ideal clinical educator in physiotherapy education. <i>Physiotherapy</i>, 81, 9, 506-513\nDerdall, M. and Urbanowski, R. (1995) Clinical education in Saskatchewan: A needs assessment. <i>Canadian Journal of Occupational Therapy</i>, 62, 3, 148-153\nErnest, M. (1985) A comprehensive field placement evaluation instrument: History, development and implications. <i>Canadian Journal of Occupational Therapy</i>, 52, 1, 25-29\nErnest, M. and Polatajko, H. (1986) Performance Evaluation of Occupational Therapy Students: A Validity Study. <i>Canadian Journal of Occupational Therapy</i>, 53, 5, 265-271\nFinlay, L. (1998) Reflexivity: an Essential Component for All Research? <i>British Journal of Occupational Therapy</i>, 61(10)\nGirot, E. (1993) Assessment and competence in clinical practice. <i>Nurse Education Today</i>, 13, 2, 83-90\nHeath, L.A. (1996) The Use of Self-Directed Learning during Fieldwork Education: The Students’ Perspective. <i>British Journal of Occupational Therapy</i>, 59, 11, 515-519\nHuddleston, R. (1999) Clinical placements for the professions allied to medicine, Part 1: A summary. <i>British journal of Occupational Therapy</i>, 62, 5, 213-219\nHummell, J. (1997) Effective Fieldwork Supervision: Occupational therapy students’ perspectives. <i>Australian Occupational Therapy Journal</i>, 44, 147-157\nJacobs, T. (1996) Integrating assessment in problem focussed curricula. <i>British Journal of Occupational Therapy</i>, 60, 4, 174-178\nJongbloed, L. (2000) Choosing the methodology to explore the research. In K.W. Hammell, C. Carpenter and I. Dyck (Eds) <i>Using Qualitative Research: A practical introduction for Occupational and Physical Therapists</i>. London: Churchill Livingstone\nKilminster, S. and Jolly, B. (2000) Effective supervision in clinical practice settings: A literature review. <i>Medical Education</i>, 34, 827-840\nKnight, J. (1998) A Fieldwork Award: Rewarding excellence in practice. <i>British Journal of Occupational Therapy</i>, 61, 7\nKrefting, L. (1991) Rigor in Qualitative Research: The assessment of trustworthiness. <i>American Journal of Occupational Therapy</i>, 45, 3, 214-222\nKrefting, L. and Krefting, D. (1991) Leisure Activities after a Stroke: An Ethnographic Approach. <i>American Journal of Occupational Therapy</i>, 45, 5, 429-436\nMartin, M. (1996) How Reflective is Student Supervision? A study of supervision in action. <i>British Journal of Occupational Therapy</i>. 59, 5, 229-232\nMitchell, M.M. and Kampfe, C.M. (1993) Student coping strategies and perceptions of fieldwork. <i>American Journal of Occupational Therapy</i>, 41, 6, 535-540\nMeyers, S.K, (1989) Program evaluation of occupational therapy level II fieldwork environments: A naturalistic Inquiry. <i>The occupational Therapy journal of Research</i>, 9, 6, 347-361\nOldmeadow, I. (1996) Developing clinical competence: A mastery pathway. <i>Australian Journal of Physiotherapy</i>. 42, 1, 37-44\nPolatajko, H., Lee, L., Bossers, A. (1994) Performance evaluation of occupational therapy students: A reliability study. <i>Canadian Journal of Occupational Therapy</i>, 61, 1, 20-27\nRudestam, K.E., Newton, R.R. (1992) <i>Surviving Your Dissertation: A comprehensive guide to content and process</i>. London: Sage\nSalvatori, P. (1996) Clinical competence: A review of the health care literature with a focus on occupational therapy. <i>Canadian Journal of Occupational therapy</i>, 63, 4, 260-269\nSeale, J., Gallagher, C. and Grisbrooke, J. (1996) Fieldwork educator training: Design and evaluation of an educational package. <i>British Journal of Occupational Therapy</i>, 59, 11, 529-534\nSeale, J., Chapman,. J, Davey, C. (2000) The influence of assessment on students’ motivation to learn in a therapy degree course. <i>Medical Education</i>, 34, 614-621\nSwinehart, S. and Meyers, S. (1993) Level I Fieldwork: Creating a positive experience. <i>American Journal of Occupational Therapy</i>, 47, 1, 68-73\nThompson, M. and Ryan, A. (1996, Students’ perspectives of fieldwork: Process, purpose and relationship to course work. <i>Australian Occupational Therapy Journal</i>, 43, 95-104\nToohey, S., Ryan, G. and Hughes, C. (1996) Assessing the practicum. <i>Assessment and Evaluation in Higher Education</i>, 21, 3, 215-226\nWaldron, M. (1990) <i>A Description and Analysis of Occupational therapy Students’ Experiences on Clinical Placement: A survey of third year students in three educational establishments together with the views of a selected group of supervisors</i>. Unpublished M Education Thesis. Liverpool: University of Liverpool\nWestcott, L. and Rugg, S. (2001) The computation of fieldwork achievement in occupational therapy degrees: Measuring a minefield. <i>British Journal of Occupational Therapy</i>, 64, 11\nWolf, A. (1993) <i>Assessment Issues and Problems in a Criterion Based System</i>. Stamford, Lincs: J.E.C. Potter and Son\n

Downloads

Published

2012-12-26

How to Cite

Knight, J. (2012). Assessment of fieldwork practice. The Journal of Practice Teaching and Learning, 5(1), 39-60. https://doi.org/10.1921/jpts.v5i1.298

Issue

Section

Articles