Do we need a second opinion here?

Authors

  • Chris Barron

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.1921/jpts.v5i2.307

Keywords:

practice teaching effectiveness, legal risk, performance monitoring and appraisal

Abstract

In contrast to research undertaken in other aspects of practice teaching, relatively little attention has been paid to measuring the effectiveness of practice teachers. This paper begins with an attempt to establish why it is important that we take the issue of practice teaching standards very seriously, focusing in particular on the ever increasing prospect of legal action against practice teachers alleged to be incompetent and the possibility of a connection between a practice teacher’s incompetence and his or her incompetence as a social work practitioner.

Ways of supporting and monitoring the performance of practice teachers are explored with these considerations in mind before moving on to consider how practice teachers who cannot or will not change practice which is deemed to be incompetent should be managed. The paper concludes with some final reflections with tentative suggestions as to how to monitor the practice of other social work educators.

References

Bogo, M. and Power, R. (1994) Educational methodologies and group elements in field instructor training. <i>The Clinical Supervisor</i>, 12, 2, 23\nBrown, A. and Bourne, I. (1996) <i>The Social Work Supervisor</i>. Hatfield: Open University Press\nDeal, K.H. (2002) Modifying field instructors’ supervisory approach using stage models of student development. <i>Journal of Teaching in Social Work</i>, 22, 3/4, 134, 135\nElliott, N. (1990) <i>Practice Teaching and the Art of Social Work</i>. Social Work Monographs, 88. Norwich: UEA\nEllison, M.L. (1994) Critical field instructor behaviours: Student and field instructor views. Arete, 18, 12\nEveritt, A. and Hardiker, P. (1996) <i>Evaluating for Good Practice</i>. London: Macmillan\nGignac-Caille, A-M. and Oermann, M. (2001) Student and faculty perceptions of effective clinical instructions in ADN programs. <i>Journal of Nursing Education</i>, 40, 8.\nKnight, C. (2001) The process of field instruction: BSW and MSW students’ views of effective field supervision. <i>Journal of Social Work Education</i>, 37, 2, 357\nKotzabassaki, S., Panou, M., Dimou, F., Karabagli, A., Koutsopoulou, B. and Ikonomou, U. (1997) Nursing students and faculty’s perception of the characteristics of ‘best’ and ‘worst’ clinical teachers. <i>Journal of Advanced Nursing</i>, 26, 4.\nLacerte, J. Ray, J. and Irwin, L. (1989) Recognising the educational contributions of field instructors. <i>Journal of Teaching in Social Work</i>, 3, 2, 112\nLefevre, M. (1998) ‘Recognising and addressing imbalances of power in the practice teacher/student dialectic. in H. Lawson (Ed.) <i>Practice Teaching: Changing social work</i>. London: Jessica Kingsley\nMcChesney, M.L. and Euster, G.L. (2000) Evaluation of an active learning teaching method for field instructor training. <i>Journal of Teaching in Social Work</i>, 20, 1/2, 214\nRogers, G. (1999a) Training field instructions British style. <i>Journal of Social Work Education</i>, 32, 2, 268\nRogers, G. (1996b) The voices of practice teachers in Britain and Canada: Comparing views after training. <i>Issues in Social Work Education</i>, 16, 1, 21\nSinicrope, R.F. and Cournoyer, D.E. (1990) Validity of student ratings of field instruction. <i>Journal of Social Work Education</i>, 26, 3, 271\nSkidmore, A. (1999) <i>Legal and Administrative Matters Relating to CCETSW Programmes, Including Issues Relating to Student and Candidate Suitability and Conduct</i>. London: CCETSW\nSkidmore, A. (2001) <i>Legal and Administrative Issues and Post Qualifying Programmes</i>. London: CCETSW\nUrdang, E. (1999) Becoming a field instructor: A key experience in professional development. <i>The Clinical Supervisor</i>, 18, 1, 100\nVonk, M.E., Zucrow, E. and Thyer, B. (1996) Female MSW students’ satisfaction with practicum supervision: The effect of supervisor gender. <i>Journal of Social Work Education</i>, 32, 3, 415\n

Downloads

Published

2012-12-26

How to Cite

Barron, C. (2012). Do we need a second opinion here?. The Journal of Practice Teaching and Learning, 5(2), 22-38. https://doi.org/10.1921/jpts.v5i2.307

Issue

Section

Articles