Developing an analytical framework for understanding the emergence of de‑professionalisation in health, social care and education sectors


  • Nigel Malin



This article aims to develop an analytical framework for understanding the context in which a process of de-professionalisation exists within an employment culture dominated by capitalism, globalisation and inequality. It specifically focuses upon experiences arising in health, social care and education sectors typifying that found within the British Welfare State during late modernity. Different theoretical definitions are presented to introduce an argument for a multi-dimensional approach. For example de-professionalisation may cover the removal from professional control, influence, manipulation or a destabilisation of a conventional mode of professionalisation and professional ties. Alternatively it may embody causation to appear unprofessional; or to discredit or deprive of professional status; also privately may be experienced as a weakening of status, respect or tendency away from a position of strength or equal status and be associated with measures for lessening the need for specialist knowledge and expertise. This analysis is based on a review of recent policy and practice evidence to support the notion that de-professionalisation may be defined through a lens of ‘cuts to services’ and job insecurity. It includes a case study covering the strike by NHS junior doctors which it is argued has had an impact on the image of ‘doctors as professionals’, resulting in a potential loss of public trust. De-professionalisation may be defined by financial cuts to staff training and through critiquing models of current training; or by a lowering of morale, a demoralisation or pervasive denigration of the workforce. Lastly this process may be considered as an outcome of low productivity in the workplace where a rise in low-skilled jobs becomes blamed for static wages. Increases in productivity come about as a result of deploying better raw materials, better trained or educated labour or better machines. Ordinary workers seem to have enjoyed few of the benefits of economic growth.

Keywords: ideological roots of de-professionalisation; neo-liberalism, Taylorism/Post-Fordism; health, social care and education providers; service cutbacks; reductions in training; workforce morale and productivity

Author Biography

Nigel Malin

Professor Emeritus in Social Policy


Adams, R (2017) Thousands of schools in England face big budget cuts, unions warn. The Guardian, January 4th

Adcroft, A and Willis, R (2006) Postmodernism, De‑professionalisation and Commodification (The Outcomes of Performance Measurement in Higher Education), Journal of Finance and Management in Public Services, 6, 1 43-60

Age UK (2016) The End of Formal Adult Social Care? (Author: Ben Franklin) London: Age UK

Allen, K (2016) Women still far adrift on salary and promotion - average gender pay gap now 18% and widens after women have children. The Guardian March 8th.

Allen, K (2017) In just 28 hours, top bosses are paid more than a typical salary. The Guardian, January 4th

Allsop, J and Saks, M (Eds) (2002) Regulating the Health Professions. London: Sage

Alzheimer’s Society (2016) Dementia UK- Help Us Be There For Families.

Andalo, D (2016) New nursing qualifications and apprenticeships boost care workers’ credentials. Society Guardian, 3 November

Arblaster, A (1985) The Rise and Decline of Western Liberalism. Oxford: Blackwell

Arblaster, A (2002) Democracy. (3rd ed.) Milton Keynes: Open University Press

Baumann, Z (1998) Work, Consumerism and the New Poor. Milton Keynes: Open University Press

Bawden, A (2016) Foster carers vote to unionise over pay. The Guardian, September 21st

Beatty, C and Fothergill, S (2013) Hitting the Poorest Places Hardest: The local and regional impact of welfare reform. Sheffield: SHU, Centre for Regional Economics and Social Research. ( 0. pdf)

Beck, U (1992) Risk Society: Towards a new modernity. London: Sage

Beder, S (2000) Selling The Work Ethic: From puritan pulpit to corporate PR. London: Zen Books

Beland, D (2007) The social exclusion discourse: Ideas and policy change. Policy and Politics, 35, 1, 123-39

Beveridge Report (1942) Social Insurance and Allied Services. London: HMSO

Blakemore, K and Warwick-Booth, L (2013) Social Policy: An introduction.(4th ed.) Maidenhead: Open University Press

Bochel, H and Daly, G (eds, 2014) Social Policy. (3rd ed.) Oxford: Routledge

Boffey, D (2015) Schools ‘must share teaching staff if they are to survive’. Head teachers’ leader calls for a united solution to recruitment crisis. The Observer, May 3rd

Bonoli, G and Natali, D (2012) The Politics of the Welfare State. Oxford: Oxford University Press

Bourdieu, P (1984) Distinction: A Critique of the social judgement of Taste. London: Routledge

Boyle, D, Coote, A, Sherwood, C and Slay, J (2010) Right Here, Right Now. Taking coproduction into the mainstream. London: NESTA.

Braverman, H (1974) Labour and Monopoly Capital: The degradation of work in the 20th century. New York: Monthly Review Press

Brignall, M (2016) Huge differences in youth unemployment across UK. The Guardian, May 15th

Brindle, D (2015) Fears of benefit cap for older people if councils take charge. The Guardian, 17th December.

Brindle, D (2016) ‘Bold reforms’ but only in children’s social work. The Guardian, January 27th

BMA (2016) End of Life Care and Physician-Assisted Dying. London: BMA. 203% 20 March 2016 pdf

BMA (2016) Training Needed to Meet Patients’End-Of-Life Care Needs. 14 March.

http:?// BMA-Press Releases http:?//>News> Media Centre. Press releases 28th September 2016

Brockling, U (2016) The Entrepreneurial Self: Fabricating: A NEw type of subject. London: Sage

Butler, I and Drakeford, M (2005) Scandal, Social Policy and Social Welfare. Bristol: The Policy Press

Butler, I and Drakeford, M (2011) Social Work On Trial: The Colwell Inquiry and the state of welfare. Bristol: The Policy Press

Butler, P (2016) Ministers ignored repeated warnings on Kids Company. The Guardian, February 21st

Callender, C (2012) Lifelong learning and training. in Alcock, P, May, M and Wright, S (Eds) 345-351, The Student’s Companion to Social Policy (4th ed.) Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell

Campbell, D (2015a) Prestigious hospital in special measures over staff shortage: CQC says safety being put at risk at Addenbrooke’s . The Guardian, September 22nd

Campbell, D (2015b) Seven-day NHS pledge doomed to fail, warns doctors’ chief. The Guardian, October 14th

Campbell, D (2015c) NHS bosses’ letter on staffing sparks fears for patient safety. The Guardian, October 16th

Campbell, D (2015d) Social care cuts leave 1 million pensioners struggling. The Guardian, October 21st

Campbell, D (2015e) NHS ‘wall of silence’ hampers investigation of complaints. The Guardian, December 8th

Campbell, D (2015f) Rationing in NHS hitting patient care, say doctors. The Guardian, December 9th

Campbell, D (2015g) Hospitals told to shed staff as NHS funding crisis deepens. The Guardian, December 15th

Campbell, D (2016a) NHS plans to hire Indian GPs to plug gaps in services: Ministers have failed to develop home-grown staff. The Guardian, April 8th

Campbell, D (2016b) Hospital with troubled A& E admits to four deaths after errors. The Guardian, June 18th

Campbell, D (2016c) NHS chief says junior doctors’ walkouts may put seriously ill at risk. The Guardian, September 8th

Campbell, D (2016d) NHS hospitals so full patients discharged too soon, say MPs. The Guardian, September 28th

Campbell, D (2016e) Mental health nursing numbers in sharp fall. The Guardian, November 2nd

Campbell, D (2016f) Top GP urges Tories to drop seven-day plan. The Guardian, December 15th

Campbell, D (2017) Biggest headache for NHS boss is own plan. The Guardian, February 1st

Campbell, D and Bawden, A (2016) Thousands of beds to go in NHS shake-up: major centralisation in England. The Guardian, 19th November

Campbell, D and Johnson, S (2016) Hunt’s cuts force NHS watchdog to reduce inspections: Hospitals and care homes to undergo less scrutiny. The Guardian, May 24th

Campbell, D and Siddique, H (2016) Junior doctors strike for first time in 40 years as lastditch talks end in deadlock: poll findings reveal 66% public support for action. The Guardian, January 12th

Care Act (2014) London: The Stationery Office

Care Quality Commission (CQC)(2012) The State of Health Care and Adult Social Care in England in 2011/12.

Care Quality Commission (CQC) (2015) Welcome to 2015! Care Quality Commission- Medium -CQC www. (CEO Andrea Sutcliffe quote)

Care Quality Commission (CQC) (2015) Report: Addenbrookes and the Rosie Hospitals Quality Report. 21st April.

Care Quality Commission (CQC) (2015) Annual Report 2014/15. Care Quality Commission July 21st .

Care Quality Commission (CQC) (2016) Shaping The Future: Consultation document. CQC. January 1st % 20 consultation _final_web.pdf

Care Quality Commission (CQC) (2016) CQC tells Brighton and Sussex University Hospitals

NHS Trust to improve services. www. July 14th

Care Quality Commission (CQC) (2016) Brighton and Sussex University Hospitals NHS Trust. CQC. August 17th

Care Quality Commission (CQC) (2016) State of Care Report warns adult social care is approaching a tipping point. CQC. - care-approaching a tipping point. October 13th

Care Quality Commission (CQC) (2016) St George’s CQC inspection report published?St George’s Healthcare. November 1st

Care Quality Commission (CQC) (2016) CQC launches consultation on its next phase of regulation. December 20th -nextphase- regulation

Carter, P (2016) Interview: Peter Carter, former RCN Chief Executive,> Professional. August 11th

Casey, L (2014) The National Troubled Families Programme. Social Work & Social Sciences Review, 17, 2, 57-62

Cerny, P (1997) Paradoxes of the competition state: Dynamics of political globalisation. Government and Opposition, 32, 2, 251-274

Chakrabortty, A (2016) We’re watching the death of neoliberalism - from within The Guardian, March 14th

Chakrabortty, A (2017) ‘We need the state now more than ever. But our belief in it has gone’ The Guardian, February 1st

Chamberlain, J. M. (2015) Medical Regulation, Fitness to Practice and Revalidation: A critical introduction. Bristol: The Policy Press

Chartered Institute of Personnel Development (CIPD) (2016) Graduates are ‘colonising’ jobs that don’t require degrees, says CIPD.’t- require-degrees-says-cipd. October 11th

Clarke, J and Newman, J (1997) The Managerial State: Power, politics and ideology in the remaking of social welfare. London: Sage

Clarke, J, Newman, J, Smith, N, Vidler, E and Westmarland, L (2007) Creating Citizen- Consumers: Changing publics and changing public services. London; Sage

Clarke, R (2016) These leaks show Hunt’s deception on the seven-day NHS. The Guardian, August 23rd

Clay, F (2016) ‘We have to convert the pressure and frustration to a sense of possibility’: NHS boss calls for new deal to care for the old The Guardian, January 19th

Coleman, J (1990) Foundations of Social Theory. Oxford: Oxford University Press

College of Social Work, England (2011) Professional Capabilities Framework. Available from:

Coulson, M (1998) Collaboration and Trust in Health Care Innovation, in Calnan, M and Rowe, R Trust Relations in the ‘New’ NHS: Theoretical and methodological challenges. ‘Taking stock of Trust’ ESRC Conference. LSE

Croisdale-Appleby, D (2014) Re-visioning Social Work Education: An independent review. February, London: DfE

Crossley, S (2016) ‘The Troubled Families Programme: In, for and against the state?’ in Fenger, M, Hudson, J and Needham, C (eds), Social Policy Review 28: Analysis and Debate in Social Policy, Bristol: The Policy Press

Crossley, S and Lambert, M (2017) Introduction: ‘Looking for Trouble?’ Critically examining the UK Government’s Troubled Families Programme, Social Policy and Society, 16, 1, 81-85

Daly, M (2015) Parenting Support as Policy Field: An Analytic Framework. Social Policy and Society, 14:4 597-608

Daly, M and Bray, R (2015) Parenting support in England: The bedding down of a new policy. Social Policy and Society, 14:4 633-644

Daly, M and Kelly, G (2015) Families and Poverty: Everyday life on a low income. Bristol: The Policy Press

Dandridge, N (2016) Higher Education Roundtable on Social Action, 11 May

#iwill campaign, Universities UK

Dandridge, N (2016) Universities need to share ideas on how to help poorer pupils., October 10th

Davies, W (2017) The Limits of Neoliberalism: Authority, sovereignty and the logic of competition. (Revised ed.) London: Sage

Davis, M (1980) A Multidimensional approach to individual differences in empathy. JSAS Catalog. Of Selected Documents in Psychology, 10, 85

De Zulueta (2013) Compassion in 21st century medicine: Is it sustainable? Clinical Ethics, 8 : 119-128

Deacon, B (2007) Global Social Policy aAnd Governance. London: Sage

Dean, M (1999) Governmentality: Power and Rule in Modern Society. London: Sage

Dearing Report (1997) The National Committee Of Inquiry Into Higher Education: Report Of The Committee. London: HMSO

Demailly, L (2003) L’evaluation de L’action ˙éducative comme apprentissage et négociation. Revue française de Pedagogie, 142, 1, 115-129

Demailly, L and De La Broise, P (2009) Les enjeux de la de‑professionalisation; Études de cas et pistes de travail. Socio-Logos, Revue De L’association française de Sociologie, 7 May. http://socio-logos.revues-org/2305

Demello, S and Furseth, P (2016) Innovation and Culture in Public Services: The case of independent living. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing

Department of Communities and Local Government (DCLG) (2012) Working With Troubled Families. London: DCLG

Department of Communities and Local Government (DCLG) (2013) Troubled Families Programme receives extra £200 million boost. 24 June

Department of Health (DoH) (1988) Working For Patients. Cm 555. London: HMSO. 200million-boost

Department of Health (DoH) (2012) Transforming Care: A national response to Winterbourne View Hospital. London: DoH

Department of Health (DoH)(2013) Prime Minister Responds to Mid-Staffs Public Inquiry Report. 14 April. etc Department of Health (DoH)(2016) Implementing The Five Year Forward View For Mental Health. February 1st FYFV-final.pdf

Department of Health (DoH)(2016) full CQC press release - Colchester Hospital. July Department of Health (DoH)(2016)- GOV.UK

Department of Health and Social Security (DHSS) (1972) Report of the Committee On Nursing. The Briggs Report. London: HMSO. December 15th

Department of Health and Social Security (DHSS) (1986) Neighbourhood Nursing: A focus for care. (Report of the Community Nursing Review) London: HMSO

Dixon, J (2015) The NHS has social objectives as well as economic ones: Can we reconcile them? The Observer, November 8th

Dobbins, T and Dundon, T (2016) The Chimera Of Sustainable Labour-Management Partnership’ British Journal of Management. DOI:10.1111/1467-8551.12128

Donaldson, Sir L. (2006) Good Doctors, Safer Patients: A Report by the Chief Medical Officer. DoH: London

Du Gay, P (2000) In Praise Of Bureaucracy: Weber, organisation and ethics. London: Sage

Edgell, S (2012) The Sociology of Work: Continuity and change in paid and unpaid work. (2nd ed.). London: Sage

Edmond, N and Price, M (Eds.) (2012) Professionalism in the children and young people’s workforce. in Integrated Working with Children And Young People. London: Sage (pp. 29-45 )

Elgot, J and Campbell, D (2016) Seven-day NHS ‘might not cut deaths’. Report casts doubt on key point in dispute. The Guardian, February 16th

Elliott, L (2015) Poorest parts of Britain face 40% public sector jobs cut. The Guardian, June 12th.

Elliott, L (2015) Corbyn has the vision, but his numbers don’t yet add up. The Guardian, August 21st

Elliott, L (2015) Rise in low-skilled jobs blamed for static wages. The Guardian, September 24th

Elliott, L (2016) End drive to send more to university, say HR experts. The Guardian, February 10th

Elliott, L and Allen, K (2017) UK faces return to inequality of Thatcher years. The Guardian, February 1st

Esping-Andersen, G (2002) A child-centred social investment strategy. in: Esping- Andersen, G, Gallie, D, Hemerjk, A and Myers, J (Eds.) Why We Need A New Welfare State. Oxford: Oxford University Press, (pp.26-67)

Evans, T (2013) Organisational rules and discretion in adult social work. British Journal of Social Work, 43, 4, 739-758

Evans, T (2015) Professionals and discretion in street-level bureaucracy. in Hupe, H, Hill, M and Buffat, A (Eds) Understanding Street-Level Bureaucracy Bristol: The Policy Press (pp., 279-294)

Evett, J (2009) New professionalism and new public management: Changes, continuities and consequences, Comparative Sociology, 8, 2, 247-266

Farrell, S (2016) MPs report demands industrial policy to close gender pay gap. The Guardian, March 22nd

Flynn, M (2012) Winterbourne View Hospital: A Serious Case Review. Gloucester: South Gloucestershire Safeguarding Adults Board

Foucault, M (1979) About the concept of the ‘dangerous individual’ in 19th century legal psychiatry. International Journal of Law and Psychiatry, 1, 1-18

Foucault, M (1980) Power/Knowledge. Brighton: Harvester

Fournier, V (2000) Boundary Work And The (Un)making Of The Professions. in Malin, N (Ed.) Professionalism, Boundaries and the Workplace.. London: Routledge (pp. 67-86)

Francis, R (2013) Report Of the Mid-Staffordshire NHS Foundation Trust Public Inquiry. London: The Stationery Office

Freidson, E (1970) Profession Of Medicine: A study in the sociology of applied knowledge. New York: Dodd, Mead & Co.

Freidson, E (2001) Professionalism: The 3rd Logic. Cambridge: The Polity Press (in particular Chapter 1: Professional Knowledge and Skill, pp.18-41)

Friedman, T (2000) The Lexus and the Olive Tree. London: Harper Collins

Frostenson, M (2015) Three Forms Of Professional Autonomy: De‑professionalisation Of Teachers in a New Light, in Autonomy in Education. NordSTEP, Nordic Journal of Studies in Educational Policy. July 3rd. 1: 28464

Gambetta, D (1988, ed) Trust: Making and breaking cooperative relations. Oxford: Blackwell

Gani, A (2015) It’s not just about pay, it’s about the future of the NHS. The Guardian, October 17th

Garrett, P.M (2009) ‘Transforming’ Children’s Services: Social work, neoliberalism and the ‘modern’ world. Maidenhead: Open University Press

Garrett, P.M (2014) Children and Families (Critical and Radical Debates in Social Work) Bristol: The Policy Press

Garson, B (1988) The Electronic Sweatshop: How computers are transforming the office of the future into the factory of the past. New York: Simon & Schuster

Gayle, D (2016) ‘Women’s refuges put at risk by benefit changes’, says charity. The Guardian, May 18th

Giddens, A (1971) Capitalism and Modern Social Theory: An analysis of the writings of Marx, Durkheim and Max Weber. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press

Giddens, A (1991) Modernity and Self-Identity. Cambridge: Polity Press

Gilbert, N (2002) Transformation Of The Welfare State: The silent surrender of public responsibility. Oxford: Oxford University Press

Glasby, J and Daly, G (2014) Adult health and social care, in Bochel, H and Daly, G (Eds.) Social Policy. (3rd ed.) 277-297. London: Routledge

Grant, L and Kinman, G (2013) The Importance of Emotional Resilience for Staff and Students in the Helping Professions. York: The Higher Education Academy

Grant, L and Kinman, G (2014) Developing Resilience for Social Work Practice. London: Palgrave Macmillan

Gray, A.M and Birrell, D (2013) Transforming Adult Social Care: Contemporary policy and practice. Bristol: The Policy Press

Greer, S , Wismar, M and Figueras, J (Eds.) (2016) Strengthening Health System Governance: Better policies, stronger performance. Maidenhead: McGraw-Hill

Guardian.letters@The 23rd December, 2016

Ham, C (2016) Plenary 3: Delivering Better Value in the NHS/NHS Scotland Event.

Ham, C (2016) An Interview With Chris Ham, Chief Executive of the Kings Fund -BMJ Blogs -the-kingsfund

Harris, J (2016) Class action and special measures. The Guardian, G2 October 11th

Harrison, S and Smith, C (2004) Trust And Moral Motivation: Redundant resources in health and social care. Bristol: The Policy Press

Hayek, F. von (1944) The Road To Serfdom. London: Routledge

Health and Care Professions Council (HCPC) (2012) Standards Of Proficiency -Social Workers In England. London: Health and Care Professions Council. Available at: www.hpcuk. org/publications/standards/index.asp?id

Heywood, A (2000) Key Concepts In Politics. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan

Hill, A (2017) ‘New’ adults will add to care crisis. The Guardian, January 25th

Hill, M and Hupe, P (2014) Implementing Public Policy. (3rd ed.) London: Sage

Howard, E (2016) Going into legal aid work now is career suicide. Society Guardian January 6th

Hunt, J (2014) ‘Francis Effect’ on NHS care one year on from Mid-Staffordshire Inquiry. Press release via Department of Health (DoH) February 6th

Hunt, J (2016) Jeremy Hunt skips all 7 NHS crisis meetings in his department despite… 13 September. Pre-release access request-NHS Improvement

Hunt, T (2016) Inequality: A problem schools alone can’t fix. The Guardian, January 12th

Inman, P (2016) Workers on zero-hours lose £1,000 a year, a study shows. The Guardian, December 30th

Jay, P (1979) Report Of The Committee Of Enquiry into Mental Handicap Nursing and Care. Vols I and II (Cmnd 7468). London: HMSO

Jordan, B (2001) Tough love: Social Work, Social exclusion and The Third Way, British Journal of Social Work, 31, 4, 527-546

Joseph Rowntree Fund (JRF) (2016) Children’s centres on their own cannot protect families against poverty, Working Paper prepared by Prof. Eva Lloyd, University of East London

Joseph Rowntree Fund (JRF) (2016) Creating An Anti-Poverty Childcare System -Joseph Rowntree Foundation token=WExVHJF_& file type…report by Adam Butler and Jill Rutter, Family and Child Care Trust

Kelly, S (2015) The ‘atomised’ council is here to stay, stripped back to the most basic services. The Guardian, December 2nd

Kirkpatrick, I , Ackroyd, S and Walker, R (2005) The New Managerialism and Public Service Professions. Change in health, social services and housing. New York: Palgrave Macmillan

Kitzinger, J (2000) Media templates: Patterns Of Association And The (Re) construction Of Meaning Over Time. Media, Culture & Society, 22, 1, 61-84

Klein, R (2010, 6th Edition) The New Politics of The NHS: From creation to reinvention. Oxford: Radcliffe Publishing

Knights, R (2015) The many reasons why there’s a teacher shortage. October 13th

Kuhlmann, E (2006) Modernising Health Care: Reinventing professions, the state and the public. Bristol: The Policy Press

Kuhlmann, E and Saks, M (Eds.) (2008) Rethinking Professional Governance: International directions in health care. Bristol: The Policy Press

Lacey, P (2001) Support Partnerships: Collaboration in action. London; David Fulton

Lambie-Mumford, H (2015) Britain’s Hunger Crisis: Where’s The Social Policy? in Irving, Z, Fenger, M and Hudson, J (Eds.) Social Policy Review 27. Bristol: The Policy Press

Laming, H (2009) The Protection Of Children In England: A Progress Report. London: House of Commons

Larson, M (1977) The Rise of Professionalism: A sociological analysis. London: University of California Press

Lavalette, M (2011) ‘Introduction’ in Radical Social Work Today: Social work at the crossroads. Bristol: The Policy Press

Lehmann Nielsen, V (2015) Law enforcement behaviour of regulatory inspectors. in Hupe, P, Hill, M and Buffat, A. (Eds.) Understanding Street-Level Bureaucracy Bristol: The Policy Press (pp.115-132)

Leonard Cheshire Disability Organisation (2016) Care Homes, Adult Day Care Centres. http: www/

Leonard Cheshire Disability Organisation (2016) file-datasets-IATI Registry. -org

Lightfoot, L (2016) Nearly half of teachers plan to leave in next five years. Survey shows huge numbers of staff in England at breaking point over their workload. The Guardian Teacher Network Survey, March 22nd

Lipsey, R (1979) An Introduction to Positive Economics. (5th ed.) London: Weidenfeld & Nicolson

Lipsky, M (1980 and 2010 versions) Street-Level Bureaucracy: Dilemmas of the individual in public services. (30th anniversary expanded ed.) New York: Russell Sage Foundation

Lister, R (2015) Poverty Beyond The Statistics by Professor Ruth Lister. YouTube February 20th Uploaded by the British Academy;

Lister, R (2016) Poverty: Key concepts. London: Sage

Lowton, K, Hiley, C and Higgs, P (2017) Constructing embodied identity in a ‘new’ ageing population : A qualitative study of the pioneer cohort of childhood liver transplant recipients in the UK. Social Science & Medicine, 172, 1-9.

Lyotard, J (1984{1979}) The Postmodern Condition: A report on knowledge. Minneapolis: Minnesota University Press

MacDonald, K.M (1995) The Sociology of the Professions. London: Sage

Mahon, R (2013) Social Investment According To The OECD/DELSA: A Discourse In The Making. Global Policy, 4 (2) 150-59

Malin, N, Manthorpe, J, Race, D and Wilmot, S (1999) Community Care for Nurses and the Caring Professions. Buckingham: Open University Press

Manthorpe, J (1999) Carers’ perspectives: Do services support carers? in Malin, N, Manthorpe, J, Race, D and Wilmot, S Community Care for Nurses and the Caring Professions. Buckingham: Open University Press (pp. 138-144)

Manthorpe, J (2002) Community care and family policy. in Malin, N, Wilmot, S and Manthorpe, J Key Concepts and Debates In Health and Social Policy. Buckingham: Open University Press (pp. 110-122,)

Marston, G and McDonald, C (2012) Getting beyond ‘heroic agency’ in conceptualising social workers as policy actors in the twenty-first century. British Journal of Social Work, 42,, 6, 1022-1038

Mason, R (2016) Ministers to focus on struggling families. The Guardian, November 19th

Mason, R and Adams, R (2015) Tory education plans ‘are election gimmicks’. The Guardian, February 2nd

McKenzie, L (2016) Narrative, ethnography and class inequality : Taking Bourdieu into a British council estate. in Thatcher, J, Ingram, N, Burke, C and Abrahams, J (Eds.) Bourdieu: The Next Generation. Oxford: Routledge (pp. 25-36)

McVeigh, T (2016) ‘Reckless’ cuts in student nurse funding attacked. The Times, June 19th Meikle, J (2016) NHS deficit hits £2.3bn as care demands rise. The Guardian, February 20th

Mendoza, K (2015) Austerity: The demolition of the welfare state and the rise of the zombie economy. New York: New Internationalist

Milburn, A (2016) Chair of the Social Mobility Commission: State Of The Nation Report on Social Mobility In Great Britain. GOV.UK.

Millar, F (2016) Teacher recruitment ‘a mess’ as every school slugs it out for itself. The Guardian Education. January 19th

Millar, F (2016) School reforms widen poverty gap, new research finds. Education Guardian.>Education. Free schools August 2nd

Millar, F (2016) education/Inequality in Education www. The Guardian, December 3rd

Mirowski, P (2013) Never Let a Serious Crisis Go to Waste: How neoliberalism survived the financial meltdown. London: Verso

Montgomery, D (1987) The Fall Of The House Of Labour: The workplace, the state and American labour activism, 1865-1925. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press

Morel, N, Palier, B, Palme, J (eds,2012) Towards a Social Investment Welfare State? Ideas, policies and challenges. Bristol: The Policy Press

Morris, K, Featherstone, B, Gupta, A, Warner, J (2016) Let’s stop feeding the risk monster: Towards a social model of child protection. Families, Relationships and Societies


Morris, K and White, S (2016) Family Complexity and Social Work: A Comparative study of family-based welfare work in different welfare regimes. NORFACE: Workshop -Discussing Key Challenges to Today’s Globalised World: Tensions Between Migration And the National Welfare State

Morris, K, Laid, S, Archard, P and Clawson, R (2017) Working with the whole family: What case files tell us about social work practices. Child & Family Social Work

doi: 10.1111/cfs.12349

Mulholland, H (2015) Nurse shortages are life-threatening. The Guardian, September 2nd

Munro, E (2011) The Munro Review Of Child Protection. Final Report. A child-centred system. Department For Education (DfE) Cm 8062. Norwich: The Stationery Office

Murphy, P (2015) Universities And Innovation Economies: The creative wasteland of postindustrial society. Farnham: Ashgate

Murray, K (2015) ‘We are not child-snatchers or do-gooders. The work we do save lives’ The Guardian, December 9th

Narey, M (2014) Making the Education of Social Workers Consistently Effective. (Report Of Sir Martin Narey’s Independent Review Of The Education Of Children’s Social Workers) January. London: DfE. Policy-GOV.UK

National Audit Office (2014) Care Quality Commission: Recruitment and training of staff to build a new organisational culture. London: National Audit Office (NAO) July 22nd

NHS (National Health Service) available at: https:?/

NHS England (2016) Nine out of ten nhs groups failing on cancer care: Ratings show need for improvement. NHS October 4th

NHS England (2016) NHS groups ‘failing’ cancer patients - Local -Yourauthority…’failing’-cancer-patients/41784 October 5th

Needham, C and Glasby, J (Eds.) (2014) Debates in Personalisation. Bristol: The Policy Press

Nellis, M (2016) Expanding Tagging Sentences. Scottish Government News. October 4th

Newman, J (2005) Bending bureaucracy: leadership and multi-level governance. in du Gay, P (Ed.) The Values Of Bureaucracy. Oxford: Oxford University Press (pp. 191-210)

Noel, A (2006) A new global politics of poverty. Global Social Policy, 6, 304-333

Noordegraaf, M (2011) Risky business: How professionals and professionals’ fields (must) deal with organizational issues. Organization Studies, 32, 10, 1349-1371

Nursing and Midwifery Council of UK (2010) Standards For Medicines Management. London: NMC

Nursing and Midwifery Council of UK (2015) The Code: Standards of conduct, performance and ethics for nurses and Midwives. London: NMC

O’Carroll, L and Halliday, J (2016) Rotherham victims will ask court to force police to hand over abuse files. The Guardian, February 26th

Office Of The Children’s Commissioner (OCC) (2014) ‘I Thought I Was The Only One. The Only One In The World’: Interim Report. November 17th

Office Of the Children’s Commissioner (OCC) (2014) ‘They Still Need To Listen More’: A Report about disabled children and young people’s rights in England. November 18th

Office Of The Children’s Commissioner (OCC) (2016) Lighting Review: Children’s access to school nurses to improve wellbeing and protect them from harm. September. Also CEO Anne Longfield’s response to the Internal Review Of The Independent Inquiry Into Child Sexual Abuse, December 16th

Orr, D (2016) This is the NHS: Mental Health ‘There is support out there - make use of it’. The Guardian, January 27th

Parker, J and Bradley, G (2014) Social Work Practice. (4th ed.). London: Sage/Learning Matters

Peck, J (2010) Constructions Of Neoliberal Reason. Oxford: Oxford University Press

Perraudin, F (2016) Rotherham aims for re-birth as town that puts children first. The Guardian, May 31st

Posner, R (2002) Anti-trust Law: An economic perspective. Chicago: University of Chicago Press

Power, M (1999) The Audit Society: Rituals Of verification. Oxford: Oxford University Press

Power, M (2014) Living in an Audit Society: Performance reporting after the global financial crisis. Public Lecture at the Schools of Social Work and Human Services and Education. The University of Queensland. April 9th

Pritchard, C (2016) Professor Colin Pritchard, Bournemouth University, gives his views on the current problems facing the NHS www. July 31st

Putnam, R (2015) Our Kids: The American dream in crisis. New York: Simon & Schuster

Quinn, B (2015) Only 1 in 8 child abuse victims come forward. The Guardian, November 24th

Quinn, B (2016) Surgeons operated on wrong parts of patients, CQC finds: Culture of bullying at Brighton & Sussex Trust. The Guardian, August 17th

Quinn, B and Campbell, D (2016) NHS vows to transform mental health services with extra £1bn a year. The Guardian, February 15th

Quinney, A and Hafford-Letchfield, T (2012) Interprofessional Social Work -Effective collaborative approaches. London: Sage/Learning Matters

Reich, R (2015) Saving Capitalism: For the many, not the few. Berkeley: University of California Press

Resolution Foundation (2017) As Time Goes By: Shifting incomes and inequality between and within generations.> Publications. 4th Report For The Intergenerational commission. February 13th

Ribbens-McCarthy, J and Edwards, R (2011) Key Concepts In Family Studies. London: Sage

Rogers, A and Pilgrim, D (2014) A Sociology Of Mental Health and Illness (5th ed.) Maidenhead: Open University Press

Rogers, J, Bright, L and Davies, H (2015) Social Work With Adults. London: Sage

Rogowski, S (2011) Managers, Managerialism and Social Work With Children And Families: The Deformation Of A Profession? Practice, 23(3): 157-67

Rogowski, S (2016) Social Work With Children And Families: Reflections Of A Critical Practitioner. Abingdon: Routledge

Rosenau, P (1991) Postmodernism and the Social Sciences: Insights, inroads and intrusions. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press

Rothblatt, S (1997) The Modern University and its Discontents. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press

Royal College Of Nursing (RCN) (2016)?BMA letter to PM David Cameron regarding bursaries. Nursing Removing Nurse Bursaries - Latest Policy Updates -

Ruch, G (2008) Post-Qualifying Child Care Social Work: Developing reflective practice. London: Sage

Rustin, S (2016) It’s your school. It’s personal: Meet the parents who are fighting back. The Guardian, July 12th

Savage, M and Wright, M (2016) Cameron wasted £1bn on troubled families. The Times, October 18th

Scholte, J (2005) Globalization: A critical introduction (2nd ed.) London: Macmillan

Schumpeter, J (1928) Unternehmer. in Ludwig, E , Weber, A and Wieser, F (Eds.) Handwörterbuch der Staatswissenschaften, Vol. 8. (4th Ed.) Jena (pp.476-487)

Schumpeter, J (1934) The Theory of Economic Development. London: Harper

Schumpeter, J (1976) Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy. London: Harper

Select Committee Report (2016) Gender Pay Gap Reporting. Publications. Parliament -Parliament. UK

Shore, C (2008) Audit Culture And Illiberal Governance: Universities And The Politics of Accountability. Anthropological Theory, 8, 3, 278-298

Shore, C and Wright,S (1999) Audit culture and anthropology: Neoliberalism in British higher education. The Journal Of The Royal Anthropological Institute 5, 4, 557-575

Siddique, H (2015) Hospitals told to shed staff as NHS funding crisis deepens. The Guardian, November 15th

Siddique, H (2016) Hospitals face 5-day walkout by doctors in contract fight. The Guardian, September 1st

Simmel, G (1950) The Sociology Of Georg Simmel. New York: Simon & Schuster

Skills For Care (2013) Code For Conduct for Health Care Support Workers and Adult Social Care Workers in England. Leeds: Skills for Care

Skills For Care (2013) National Minimum Training Standards for Health Care Support Workers and Adult Social Care Workers in England. Leeds: Skills For Care

Skills For Care (2015) - Skills for Care -Helping social care employers and Legislation

Smith, D (2001) The changing idea of a university. in Smith, D and Langslow, K (Eds.) The Idea of a University. London: Jessica Kingsley (pp. 148-174)

Smith, J. (2004) Safeguarding Patients. Lessons from the past, proposals for the future. 5th Report of the Shipman Inquiry. Lonson: The Stationery Office Cm 6394

Social Mobility Commission (2017) The Class Pay Gap within Britain’s Professions: The class pay gap and intergenerational worklessness. (authored by Friedman, S , Laurison, D and Macmillan, L) London: Social Mobility Commission. January 26th

Social Work Reform Board (2012) Building A Safe Confident Future: Maintaining momentum. London: DfE

Sparrow, A (2016) Junior doctors risk being struck off GMC. The Guardian, September 5th

Standing, G (2011) The Precariat: The New Dangerous Class. London: Bloomsbury

Standing, G (2014) A Precariat Charter. London: Bloomsbury Academic

Taylor, F (1947) Scientific Management. New York: Harper and Brothers.

Taylor, M (2016) Failing children’s services to be taken over by rival councils under proposed changes. The Guardian, April 15th

Taylor-Gooby, P (2008) The new welfare state settlement in Europe. European Societies, 10, 1, 3-24

Taylor-Gooby, P and Stoker, G (2011) The Coalition Programme: A new vision for Britain or politics as usual? The Political Quarterly, 82, 1, 4-15

Tett, G. The Silo Effect: Why putting everything in its place isn't such a bright idea. London: Little, Brown

Tickle, L (2017) Mother courage: Trading pregnancy for help. Society Guardian, January 25th

Toynbee, P (2015) Hunt’s hit squad is a danger to our national health. The Guardian, September 22nd

Toynbee, P (2016) Saving his skin as he lets the NHS sink. The Guardian, July 26th

Toynbee, P (2016) Our nurses are being cast into a perfect Brexit storm. The Guardian, October 14th

Treanor, J (2016) Chancellor insists foreign worker plan not aimed at banks. The Guardian, October 7th

Triseliotis, J (1995) Adoption: evolution or revolution. in British Agencies For Adoption And Fostering, Selected BAAF Seminar Papers 1994/95 London: BAAF

Triseliotis, J (1997) Foster care and adoption. in Davies, M (Ed.) The Blackwell Companion To Social Work. Oxford: Blackwell Publishers (pp.331-336)

Thomas, R and Davies, A (2005) Theorising the micro-politics of resistance: New public management and managerial identities in the UK public services. Organization Studies, 26, 5, 683-706

Thompson, M (2016) Enough Said: What’s gone wrong with the language of politics. Harmondsworth: Penguin

Tunstill, J (2016) Editorial: In defence of progressive social work. Social Work & Social Sciences Review,, 18, 2, 3-6

Vallos, S (1990) The concept of skill: A critical review. Work and Occupations, 17, 4, 379-398

Van der Aa, P and van Berkel, R (2015) Fulfilling The promise of professionalism in street- level practice, 263-278 in Hupe, P, Hill, M and Buffat, A (Eds.) Understanding Street-Level Bureaucracy. Bristol: The Policy Press

Walker, P, Stewart, H and Taylor, D (2016) NHS bosses defend shake-up after planned cuts cause alarm. The Guardian, August 27th

Weale, S (2015) Without Kids Company I’d be dead or in prison. Its closure was a big shock to me. The Guardian, September 22nd

Weale, S (2015) Schools hit by record £1.3bn supply staff bill, says Labour. The Guardian, December 14th

Weale, S (2016) Ministers childcare policies ‘fail to deliver’: demand for better paid and better qualified staff. The Guardian, January 27th

Weale, S (2016) Parents see fees go up after big fall in number of childminder places. The Guardian, February 8th

Weale, S (2016) Third of new teachers quit within five years: Unions blame workload and constant changes. The Guardian, August 5th

Weale, S (2016) Grammar schools plan risks disaster, warns social mobility tsar. The Guardian, September 8th

Weber, M (1976{1930} ) The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism. London: Allen & Unwin

Weber, M (1991) Science as a vocation. in From Max Weber: Essays in sociology (new edition) London: Routledge

Weber, S (1987) The limits of professionalism. in Weber, S Institution and Interpretation. Theory And History of Literature,31: 19-32, Minneapolis: University Of Minneapolis Press

White, S (2004) Welfare philosophy and the third way., in Lewis, J and Surender, R (Eds.) Welfare State Change: Towards a third way? Oxford: Oxford University Press

Whitehead, S (2016) Pay the cost of caring: ‘I love my job, but I’m tired’. The Guardian, June 25th

Wilby, P (2016) Eton’s Provost: Social mobility improving, but real change is … The Guardian, May 13th

Williams, M (2016) Key Concepts in the Philosophy of Social Research. London: Sage

Williams, P (2012) The role of leadership in learning and knowledge for integration: Nanaging community Care. Journal Of Integrated Care, 20, 3. 164-174

Wintour, P (2014) Labour: 430,000 students taught by unqualified staff. The Guardian, December 30th

Wolfensberger, W (1972) The Principle Of Normalization In Human Services. Toronto: NIMR

Wolfensberger, W (1998) Social Role Valorization. (3rd ed.) Syracuse, NY: Syracuse University, Training Institute On Human Service Planning, Leadership And Change Agency

Women’s Aid Federation Of England (2016) Support for Survivors: Refuge. Who can stay at a refuge? Women’s Aid (@womensaid)?Twitter. SOS: Save Refuges, Save Lives-Women’s Aid https;//www. Campaign with us September

Wood, S (ed, 1982) The Degradation Of Work? Skill, des‑skilling and the labour process. London: Hutchinson




How to Cite

Malin, N. (2017). Developing an analytical framework for understanding the emergence of de‑professionalisation in health, social care and education sectors. Social Work and Social Sciences Review, 19(1), 66-162.