Assessing the impact and implications for social workers of an innovative children’s services programme aimed to support workforce reform and integrated working

Nigel Malin; Jane Tunmore

doi:10.1921/swssr.v16i3.538

Authors

Nigel Malin
Jane Tunmore

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.1921/swssr.v16i3.538

Keywords:

evaluation, child poverty, inter-professional working, managerialism, workforce reform, health and social care

Abstract

This article reports findings from an independent audit and evaluation of an innovative children's services programme (CSP) funded 2009-2011 by twelve Local Authorities under the auspices of the North-East of England's Improvement & Efficiency Partnership (NEIEP) to manage improvements and efficiencies across the children's services sector focusing upon messages for social workers. The overall purpose of the CSP was to make demonstrable progress in tackling the challenges of child poverty by delivering high quality support to the growing number of children with social care/health needs through regional improvement. The key objectives of the CSP included supporting workforce reform and integrated working; development of personalised services; family support to reduce the need for residential care; and provision of tools to aid commissioners with needs analysis. The audit identified key outputs, for example, improvements to best practice on Whole Family approaches, safeguarding and leadership training evolved through a skills framework; and included a regional model of social work supervision training along with a provision of options to increase the range and quality of foster care placements. The evaluation considered actions arising from the above findings, including demonstrated improvements to inter-disciplinary working and pooling resources to produce better outcomes for families; setting up a data-base to improve the balance between fostering, residential care and family support; and creating opportunities for social workers to explore the practical implementation of using personal budgets.

References

Atkinson, M (2006) The development of an evaluation framework for partnership-working. British Journal of Management, 7, 1, 75-86nBäckmnn, O and Ferrarini, T (2010) Combating child poverty? A multilevel assessment of family policy institutions and child poverty in 21 old and new welfare states, Journal of Social Policy, 39, 2 AprilnBessell, S (2009) Children’s participation in decision-making in the Philippines: Understanding the attitudes of policy-makers and service providers, Childhood, 16, 3, 299-316nBoyle, D, Coote, A, Sherwood, C and Slay, J (2010) Right Here, Right Now: Taking co-production into the mainstream. Discussion Paper. NESTA www.nesta.org.uk http://www.nesta.org.uk'>www.nesta.org.uknBuse, K, Mays, N and Walt, G (2005) Making Health Policy. Maidenhead: Open University PressnChurchill, H and Clarke, K (2009) Investing in parenting education: A critical review of policy and provision in England. Social Policy and Society, 9, 1, 39-53nChristie, D and Menmuir, J (2005) A common standards framework as a catalyst for inter-professional collaboration in teaching and the caring professions. Policy Futures in Education, 3, 1, 62-74nCornes, M et al (2011) ‘Grow Your Own’ Social Work Agency Implementation. Report Series No. 4. SCWRU. Kings College LondonnCutler, T and Waine, B (1998) Managing the Welfare State. Oxford: Berg CivitasnDavis, J (2011) Integrated Children’s Services. London: Sage.nDCSF (2008) Building Brighter Futures : Next steps for the children’s workforce. Nottingham : Department for Children, Schools and Families Publications,nDH (2004) Every Child Matters: Change for children. London: Department of HealthnDH (2007) Direct Payments Uptake Project : In control. London: Department of HealthnDH/Care Services Improvement Partnership /In Control (2008) Individual Budgets: Living your life, your way. Department of Health DVDnFisher, M (2012) Beyond evidence-based policy and practice: Reshaping the relationship between research and practice. Social Work & Social Sciences Review, 16, 2, 20-36nFitoussi, J, Stiglitz, J and Sen, A (2009) Report of the Commission on the Measurement of Economic Performance and Social Progress, Paris, www stiglitz-sen-fitoussi-fr/documents/ rapport anglais. Pdf (accessed 12 Nov 2009) www stiglitz-sen-fitoussi-fr/documents/rapport anglais.PdfnFitzgerald, D and Kay, J (2008) Working Together in Children’s Services. London: Routledge/David FultonnFox, M, Martin, P and Green, G (2008) Doing Practitioner Research. London: SagenGlenny, G and Roaf, C (2008) Multiprofessional Communication: Making systems work for children. Maidenhead: Open University Press / McGraw-Hill EducationnHafford-Letchfield, T (2009) Management and Organisation in Social Work. 2 ^nd Ed. www.learningmatters.co.uk http://www.learningmatters.co.uk'>www.learningmatters.co.uknHM Treasury and DfES (2007) Aiming Higher for Disabled Children. Nottingham: Department for Education and SciencenHM Treasury (2011) Budget 2011 HC 836, London: HM TreasurynHome Office (2011) More Effective Responses to Anti-Social Behaviour. London: Home OfficenHothersall, S (2006) Social Work with Children, Young People and Their Families in Scotland. http://www.learningmatters.co.uk'>www.learningmatters.co.uknJones, N and Sumner, A (2011) Child Poverty, Evidence and Policy: Mainstreaming Children in International Development. Bristol: www.policypress.co.uk http://www.policypress.co.uk'>www.policypress.co.uknJulkunen, I (2011) Critical elements in evaluating and developing practice in social work: An exploratory overview. Social Work & Social Sciences Review, 15, 1, 74-91nKahan, B (2008) Excerpts from Review of Evaluation Frameworks. Kael Consulting: Saskatchewan Ministry of EducationnKNOTS (Knowledge, Technology and Society Group, IDS) (2006) Understanding Policy Processes: A review of IDS research on the environment. Brighton: IDSnLewis, J, Roberts, J and Finnegan, C (2011) Making the Transition from Sure Start local programmes to children’s centres, 2003-2008. Journal of Social Policy, 40, 3, 437-452nMcGregor, J (2007) Researching well-being: From concepts to methodology. in I. Gough and J. McGregor (Eds) Well-Being in Developing Countries: New approaches and research strategies. Cambridge: Cambridge University PressnMiner, J (1988) Concepts of culture. in J. Miner Organisational Behaviour. New York: Random House (pp.559-562)nNFER (2010) Implementing Outcomes-Based Accountability in Children’s Services: An overview of the process and impact. Slough: NFERnNoble, J, Harris, M and Manthorpe, J (2010) Grow Your Own Workers: A toolkit. London: SCWRU, Kings College, University of LondonnNorth-East Improvement and Efficiency Partnership (NEIEP, 2009) Draft Specification of Evaluation Protocol. Guildhall, Quayside, Newcastle upon Tyne NE1 3AFnPeck, E and Dickinson, H (2008) Managing and Leading in Inter-agency Settings. Bristol: Policy PressnPinkney, S (2011) Discourses of children’s participation: Professionals, policies and practices. Social Policy and Society, 10, 3, 271-283nPurcell, C and Chow, D (2010) The Reorganisation of children’s social services in England: Emergent themes. Public Money and Management, 31, 4 152-160nScott, F (2006) The Representation of Integration in Guidance and Documents relating to Children’s Services Plans. MSc Childhood Studies thesis. Edinburgh: University of Edinburgh, Graduate School of Social and Political StudiesnShaw, I and Gould, N (2001) Qualitative Research in Social Work. London: SagenSocial Work Reform Board (2010) Building a Safe and Confident Future: One year on. London: Social Work Reform BoardnSocial Work Reform Board (2011) Professional Capability Framework for Social Workers in England. London: Social Work Reform BoardnStewart, K (2011) A treble blow? Child poverty in 2010 and beyond. in C. Holden, M. Kilkey, and G. Ramia (Eds.) Social Policy Review 23. Analysis and Debate in Social Policy. Bristol: Policy PressnThornley, C (2007) Efficiencies and equity considerations in the employment of health care assistants and support workers. Social Policy and Society, 7, 2, 147-158nTrodd, E and Chivers, L (2011) Inter-professional Working. Maidenhead: Open University PressnUNICEF (2005) State of the World’s Children. New York: UNICEFnWhetten, D and Godfrey, P (1998) (Eds.) Identity in Organisations : Building theory through conversations. London: Sagen